This lock was only needed to protect the buffer_wq list, but now we have
the mt_list for this. This patch simply turns the buffer_wq list to an
mt_list and gets rid of the lock.
It's worth noting that the whole buffer_wait thing still looks totally
wrong especially in a threaded context: the wakeup_cb() callback is
called synchronously from any thread and may end up calling some
connection code that was not expected to run on a given thread. The
whole thing should probably be reworked to use tasklets instead and be
a bit more centralized.
Since last commit there's no point anymore in having two variants of the
same function, let's switch to b_free() only. __b_drop() was renamed to
__b_free() for obvious consistency reasons.
A small race exists in buffers with "show sess all". This one wants to show
some information grabbed from the buffer (especially in HTX mode). But the
thread owning this buffer might just be releasing its area, right after a
free() or munmap() call, resulting in a head that is not seen as empty yet
though the area was released. It may then be dereferenced by "show sess all"
causing a crash. Note that in practice it only happens in debug mode with
UAF enabled, but it's tricky enough to fix it right now.
This should be backported to stable versions which support threads and a
store barrier. It's worth noting that by performing the clearing first,
b_free() and b_drop() now become two exact equivalent.
In lock profiles it's visible that there is a huge contention on the
buffer lock. The reason is that when offer_buffers() is called, it
systematically takes the lock before verifying if there is any
waiter. However doing so doesn't protect against races since a
waiter can happen just after we release the lock as well. Similarly
in h2 we take the lock every time an h2c is going to be released,
even without checking that the h2c belongs to a wait list. These
two have now been addressed by verifying non-emptiness of the list
prior to taking the lock.
Haproxy is designed to be able to continue to run even under very low
memory conditions. However this can sometimes have a serious impact on
performance that it hard to diagnose. Let's report counters of failed
pool and buffer allocations per thread in show activity.
Having a thread_local for the pool cache is messy as we need to
initialize all elements upon startup, but we can't until the threads
are created, and once created it's too late. For this reason, the
allocation code used to check for the pool's initialization, and
it was the release code which used to detect the first call and to
initialize the cache on the fly, which is not exactly optimal.
Now that we have initcalls, let's turn this into a per-thread array.
This array is initialized very early in the boot process (STG_PREPARE)
so that pools are always safe to use. This allows to remove the tests
from the alloc/free calls.
Doing just this has removed 2.5 kB of code on all cumulated pool_alloc()
and pool_free() paths.
Instead of exporting a number of pools and having to manually delete
them in deinit() or to have dedicated destructors to remove them, let's
simply kill all pools on deinit().
For this a new function pool_destroy_all() was introduced. As its name
implies, it destroys and frees all pools (provided they don't have any
user anymore of course).
This allowed to remove 4 implicit destructors, 2 explicit ones, and 11
individual calls to pool_destroy(). In addition it properly removes
the mux_pt_ctx pool which was not cleared on exit (no backport needed
here since it's 1.9 only). The sig_handler pool doesn't need to be
exported anymore and became static now.
Each thread now keeps the last ~512 kB of freed objects into a local
cache. There are some heuristics involved so that a specific pool cannot
use more than 1/8 of the total cache in number of objects. Tests have
shown that 512 kB is an optimal size on a 24-thread test running on a
dual-socket machine, resulting in an overall 7.5% performance increase
and a cache miss ratio reducing from 19.2 to 17.7%. Anyway it seems
pointless to keep more than an L2 cache, which probably explains why
sizes between 256 and 512 kB are optimal.
Cached objects appear in two lists, one per pool and one LRU to help
with fair eviction. Currently there is no way to check each thread's
cache state nor to flush it. This cache cannot be disabled and is
enabled as soon as the lockless pools are enabled (i.e.: threads are
enabled, no pool debugging is in use and the CPU supports a double word
CAS).
Now the buffers only contain the header and a pointer to the storage
area which can be anywhere. This will significantly simplify buffer
swapping and will make it possible to map chunks on buffers as well.
The buf_empty variable was removed, as now it's enough to have size==0
and area==NULL to designate the empty buffer (thus a non-allocated head
is the empty buffer by default). buf_wanted for now is indicated by
size==0 and area==(void *)1.
The channels and the checks now embed the buffer's head, and the only
pointer is to the storage area. This slightly increases the unallocated
buffer size (3 extra ints for the empty buffer) but considerably
simplifies dynamic buffer management. It will also later permit to
detach unused checks.
The way the struct buffer is arranged has proven quite efficient on a
number of tests, which makes sense given that size is always accessed
and often first, followed by the othe ones.
This one is more generic and designed to work on a random block. It
may later get a b_rep_ist() variant since many strings are already
available as (ptr,len).
There was no point keeping that function in the buffer part since it's
exclusively used by HTTP at the channel level, since it also automatically
appends the CRLF. This further cleans up the buffer code.
The new file istbuf.h links the indirect strings (ist) with the buffers.
The purpose is to encourage addition of more standard buffer manipulation
functions that rely on this in order to improve the overall ease of use
along all the code. Just like ist.h and buf.h, this new file is not
expected to depend on anything beyond these two files.
A few functions were added and/or converted from buffer.h :
- b_isteq() : indicates if a buffer and a string match
- b_isteat() : consumes a string from the buffer if it matches
- b_istput() : appends a small string to a buffer (all or none)
- b_putist() : appends part of a large string to a buffer
The equivalent functions were removed from buffer.h and changed at the
various call places.
The two variants now do exactly the same (appending at the tail of the
buffer) so let's not keep the distinction between these classes of
functions and have generic ones for this. It's also worth noting that
b{i,o}_putchk() wasn't used at all and was removed.
There's no distinction between in and out data now. The latter covers
the needs of the former and supports wrapping. The extra cost is
negligible given the locations where it's used.
Since we never access this field directly anymore, but only through the
channel's wrappers, it can now move to the channel. The buffers are now
completely free from the distinction between input and output data.
This is intentionally the minimal and safest set of changes, some cleanups
area still required. These changes are quite tricky and cannot be
independantly tested, so it's important to keep this patch as bisectable
as possible.
buf_empty and buf_wanted were changed and are now exactly similar since
there's no <p> member in the structure anymore. Given that no test is
ever made in the code to check that buf == &buf_wanted, it may be possible
that we don't need to have two anymore, unless some buf_empty tests have
precedence. This will have to be investigated.
A significant part of this commit affects the HTTP compression code,
which used to deeply manipulate the input and output buffers without
any reasonable solution for a better abstraction. For this reason, if
any regression is met and designates this patch as the culprit, it is
important to run tests which specifically involve compression or which
definitely don't use it in order to spot the issue.
Cc: Olivier Houchard <ohouchard@haproxy.com>
For the same consistency reasons, let's use b_empty() at the few places
where an empty buffer is expected, or c_empty() if it's done on a channel.
Some of these places were there to realign the buffer so
{b,c}_realign_if_empty() was used instead.
We used to have variations around buffer_total_space() and
size-buffer_len() or size-b_data(). Let's simplify all this. buffer_len()
was also removed as not used anymore.
Now the new API functions are being used everywhere, we can get rid
of b_ptr(). A few last users like bi_istput() and bo_istput() appear
to only differ by what part of the buffer they're increasing, but
that should quickly be merged.
Till now the callers had to know which one to call for specific use cases.
Let's fuse them now since a single one will remain after the API migration.
Given that bi_del() may only be used where o==0, just combine the two tests
by first removing output data then only input.
This will be important so that we can parse a buffer without touching it.
Now we indicate where from the buffer's head we plan to start to copy, and
for how many bytes. This will be used by send functions to loop at the end
of the buffer without having to update the buffer's output byte count.
This new functoin limits itself to the amount of data available in the
buffer and doesn't care about the direction anymore. It's only called
from co_getblk() which already checks that no more than the available
output bytes is requested.
These ones were merged into a single b_contig_space() that covers both
(the bo_ case was a simplified version of the other one). The function
doesn't use ->i nor ->o anymore.
This function was sometimes used from a channel and sometimes from a buffer.
In both cases it requires knowledge of the size of the output data (to skip
them). Here the split ensures the channel can deal with this point, and that
other places not having output data can continue to work.
These ones manipulate the output data count which will be specific to
the channel soon, so prepare the call points to use the channel only.
The b_* functions are now unused and were removed.
Where relevant, the channel version is used instead. The buffer version
was ported to be more generic and now takes a swap buffer and the output
byte count to know where to set the alignment point. The H2 mux still
uses buffer_slow_realign() with buf->o but it will change later.
Here's the list of newly introduced functions :
- b_data(), returning the total amount of data in the buffer (currently i+o)
- b_orig(), returning the origin of the storage area, that is, the place of
position 0.
- b_wrap(), pointer to wrapping point (currently data+size)
- b_size(), returning the size of the buffer
- b_room(), returning the amount of bytes left available
- b_full(), returning true if the buffer is full, otherwise false
- b_stop(), pointer to end of data mark (currently p+i), used to compute
distances or a stop pointer for a loop.
- b_peek(), this one will help make the transition to the new buffer model.
It returns a pointer to a position in the buffer known from an offest
relative to the beginning of the data in the buffer. Thus, we can replace
the following occurrences :
bo_ptr(b) => b_peek(b, 0);
bo_end(b) => b_peek(b, b->o);
bi_ptr(b) => b_peek(b, b->o);
bi_end(b) => b_peek(b, b->i + b->o);
b_ptr(b, ofs) => b_peek(b, b->o + ofs);
- b_head(), pointer to the beginning of data (currently bo_ptr())
- b_tail(), pointer to first free place (currently bi_ptr())
- b_next() / b_next_ofs(), pointer to the next byte, taking wrapping
into account.
- b_dist(), returning the distance between two pointers belonging to a buffer
- b_reset(), which resets the buffer
- b_space_wraps(), indicating if the free space wraps around the buffer
- b_almost_full(), indicating if 3/4 or more of the buffer are used
Some of these are provided with the unchecked variants using the "__"
prefix, or with the "_ofs" suffix indicating they return a relative
position to the buffer's origin instead of a pointer.
Cc: Olivier Houchard <ohouchard@haproxy.com>
The buffer code currently depends on pools and other stuff and is not
really autonomous anymore. The rewrite of the new API is an opportunity
to clean this up. This patch creates a new file (buf.h) which does not
depend on other elements and which will only contain what is needed to
perform the most basic buffer operations. The new API will be introduced
in this file and the conversion will be finished once buffer.h is empty.
The definition of struct buffer was moved to this new file, using more
explicity stdint types for the sizes and offsets.
Most new functions will be implemented in two variants :
__b_something() : unchecked variant, no wrapping is expected
b_something() : wrapping-checked variant
This way callers will be able to select which one to use depending on
the use cases.
When the block of data need to be split to support the wrapping, the start of
the second block of data was wrong. We must be sure to skup data copied during
the first memcpy.
This patch must be backported to 1.8.
