mirror of https://github.com/mpv-player/mpv
manpage: updates changes.rst
The situation has changed a bit since the days of mplayer2, so we can use more/less diplomatic wording. Merge the two sections listing changes from MPlayer and mplayer2. Mention the client API and Lua scripting as alternatives to slave mode. I'm calling MPlayer code "horrible". This is not meant as an offense, but after turning around almost every line of MPlayer code, I believe I have a right to say this. Sorry. I would say that MPlayer has a surprisingly sane and simple architecture (for what it is), but much of it drowned under a load of evil hacks or not-cleaned-up-yet code.
This commit is contained in:
wm4
parent
d0a66dbd5d
commit
d6774515a7
|
|
@ -10,10 +10,16 @@ should generally be treated as a completely different program.
|
|||
.. note::
|
||||
These lists are incomplete.
|
||||
|
||||
General Changes for MPlayer to mplayer2
|
||||
---------------------------------------
|
||||
General Changes for MPlayer to mpv
|
||||
----------------------------------
|
||||
|
||||
* Removal of the internal GUI, MEncoder, OSD menu
|
||||
* Switch to GPLv2+. (Technically speaking, MPlayer as a whole seems to be
|
||||
GPLv2-only, while mplayer is GPLv3+ - see ``Copyright`` file for details.)
|
||||
* Removal of the internal GUI, MEncoder, OSD menu, video drivers for Linux 2.4
|
||||
(including VIDIX)
|
||||
* Large internal cleanups
|
||||
* Removal of support for dead platforms
|
||||
* New buildsystem
|
||||
* Better pause handling (do not unpause on a command)
|
||||
* Better MKV support (such as ordered chapters)
|
||||
* vo_vdpau improvements
|
||||
|
|
@ -34,18 +40,6 @@ General Changes for MPlayer to mplayer2
|
|||
* Screenshot improvements (instant screenshots without 1-frame delay, allow
|
||||
taking screenshots even with hardware decoding)
|
||||
* Improved support for PulseAudio
|
||||
* General code cleanups
|
||||
* Many more changes
|
||||
|
||||
General Changes for mplayer2 to mpv
|
||||
-----------------------------------
|
||||
|
||||
* Switch back to GPLv2+.
|
||||
* Removal of lots of unneeded code to encourage developer activity (less
|
||||
obscure scary zombie code that kills any desire for hacking the codebase)
|
||||
* Removal of dust and dead bodies (code-wise), such as kernel drivers for
|
||||
decades old hardware
|
||||
* Removal of support for dead platforms
|
||||
* Generally improved MS Windows support (dealing with unicode filenames,
|
||||
improved ``--vo=direct3d``, improved window handling)
|
||||
* Better OSD rendering (using libass). This has full unicode support, and
|
||||
|
|
@ -108,6 +102,9 @@ General Changes for mplayer2 to mpv
|
|||
* OSX: VDA support using libavcodec hwaccel API insted of FFmpeg's decoder. Up
|
||||
to 2-2.5x reduction in CPU usage.
|
||||
* Make hardware decoding in general work with the ``opengl`` video output.
|
||||
* Lua scripting (see `LUA SCRIPTING`_)
|
||||
* A client API, that allows embedding **mpv** into applications
|
||||
(see ``libmpv/client.h`` in the sources)
|
||||
* General bug fixes and removal of long-standing issues
|
||||
* General code cleanups (including refactoring or rewrites of many parts)
|
||||
* Many more changes
|
||||
|
|
@ -124,13 +121,11 @@ Command Line Switches
|
|||
* There is a new command line syntax, which is generally preferred over the old
|
||||
syntax. ``-optname optvalue`` becomes ``--optname=optvalue``.
|
||||
|
||||
The old syntax will not be removed in the near future. However, the new
|
||||
syntax is mentioned in all documentation and so on, so it is a good thing to
|
||||
know about this change.
|
||||
|
||||
(The new syntax was introduced in mplayer2.)
|
||||
The old syntax will not be removed. However, the new syntax is mentioned in
|
||||
all documentation and so on, and unlike the old syntax is not ambiguous,
|
||||
so it is a good thing to know about this change.
|
||||
* In general, negating switches like ``-noopt`` now have to be written as
|
||||
``-no-opt``, or better ``--no-opt``.
|
||||
``-no-opt`` or ``--no-opt``.
|
||||
* Per-file options are not the default anymore. You can explicitly specify
|
||||
file-local options. See ``Usage`` section.
|
||||
* Many options have been renamed, removed or changed semantics. Some options
|
||||
|
|
@ -280,12 +275,9 @@ input.conf and Slave Commands
|
|||
| ``af_switch``, ``af_add``, ... | ``af set|add|...`` |
|
||||
+--------------------------------+----------------------------------------+
|
||||
|
||||
Other
|
||||
~~~~~
|
||||
Slave mode
|
||||
~~~~~~~~~~
|
||||
|
||||
* The playtree has been removed. **mpv**'s internal playlist is a simple and
|
||||
flat list now. This simplifies the code and makes **mpv** usage less
|
||||
confusing.
|
||||
* Slave mode is broken. This mode is entirely insane in the ``old`` versions of
|
||||
MPlayer. A proper slave mode application needed tons of code and hacks to get
|
||||
it right. The main problem is that slave mode is a bad and incomplete
|
||||
|
|
@ -298,31 +290,52 @@ Other
|
|||
compatible. If you are a developer of a slave mode application, contact us,
|
||||
and a new and better protocol can be developed.
|
||||
|
||||
``--identify`` was already removed (``TOOLS/mpv_identify.sh`` is provided
|
||||
instead), and ``--slave-broken`` might be removed in the future.
|
||||
|
||||
* **mpv** also provides a client API, which can be used to embed the player
|
||||
by loading it as shared library. (See ``libmpv/client.h`` in the sources.)
|
||||
It might also be possible to implement a custom slave mode-like protocol
|
||||
using Lua scripting.
|
||||
|
||||
* A slave protocol is planned, but nothing has emerged yet.
|
||||
|
||||
Policy for Removed Features
|
||||
---------------------------
|
||||
|
||||
Features are a good thing, because they make users happy. As such, it is
|
||||
attempted to preserve useful features as far as possible. But if a feature is
|
||||
likely to be not used by many, and causes problems otherwise, it will be
|
||||
removed. Developers should not be burdened with fixing or cleaning up code that
|
||||
has no actual use.
|
||||
**mpv** is in active development. If something is in the way of more important
|
||||
development (such as fixing bugs or implementing new features), we sometimes
|
||||
remove features. Usually this happens only with old features that either seem
|
||||
to be useless, or are not used by anyone. Often these are obscure, or
|
||||
"inherited", or were marked experimental, but never received any particular
|
||||
praise by any users.
|
||||
|
||||
It is always possible to add back removed features. File a feature request if a
|
||||
feature you relied on has been removed, and you want it back. Though it might be
|
||||
rejected in the worst case, it is much more likely that it will be either added
|
||||
back, or that a better solution will be implemented.
|
||||
Sometimes, features are replaced by something new. The new code will be either
|
||||
simpler or more powerful, but doesn't necessarily provide everything the old
|
||||
feature did.
|
||||
|
||||
We can not exclude that we accidentally remove features that are actually
|
||||
popular. Generally, we do not know how much a specific functionality is used.
|
||||
If you miss a feature and think it should be re-added, please open an issue
|
||||
on the mpv bug tracker. Hopefully, a solution can be found. Often, it turns
|
||||
out that re-adding something is not much of a problem, or that there are
|
||||
better alternatives.
|
||||
|
||||
Why this Fork?
|
||||
--------------
|
||||
|
||||
* MPlayer wants to maintain old code, even if it is very bad code. It seems
|
||||
mplayer2 was forked because MPlayer developers refused to get rid of all the
|
||||
cruft. The mplayer2 and MPlayer codebases also deviated enough to make a
|
||||
reunification unlikely.
|
||||
* mplayer2 development is slow, and it is hard to get in changes. Details
|
||||
withheld as to not turn this into a rant.
|
||||
* MPlayer rarely merged from mplayer2, and mplayer2 practically stopped
|
||||
merging from MPlayer (not even code cleanups or new features are merged)
|
||||
* **mpv** intends to continuously merge from mplayer-svn and mplayer2, while
|
||||
speeding up development. There is willingness for significant changes, even
|
||||
if this means breaking compatibility.
|
||||
mplayer2 is practically dead, and mpv started out as a branch containing
|
||||
new/experimental development. (Some of it was merged right *after* the fork
|
||||
was made public, seemingly as an acknowledgment that development, or at
|
||||
least merging, should have been more active.)
|
||||
|
||||
MPlayer is focused on not breaking anything, but is left with a horrible
|
||||
codebase resistant to cleanup. (Unless you do what mpv did - merciless and
|
||||
consequent pruning of bad, old code.) Cleanup and keeping broken things
|
||||
conflict, so the kind of development mpv strives for can't be done within
|
||||
MPlayer due to clashing development policies.
|
||||
|
||||
Additionally, mplayer2 already had lots of changes over MPlayer, which would
|
||||
have needed to be backported to the MPlayer codebase. This would not only
|
||||
have been hard (several years of diverging development), but also would have
|
||||
been impossible due to the aforementioned MPlayer development policy.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Reference in New Issue