It was reported that a server configured with a zero weight would
sometimes still take connections from the backend queue. This issue is
real, it happens this way :
1) the disabled server accepts a request with a cookie
2) many cookie-less requests accumulate in the backend queue
3) when the disabled server completes its request, it checks its own
queue and the backend's queue
4) the server takes a pending request from the backend queue and
processes it. In response, the server's cookie is assigned to
the client, which ensures that some requests will continue to
be served by this server, leading back to point 1 above.
The fix consists in preventing a zero-weight server from dequeuing pending
requests from the backend. Making use of srv_is_usable() in such tests makes
the tests more robust against future changes.
This fix must be backported to 1.4 and 1.3.
Kai Krueger found that previous patch was incomplete, because there is
an unconditionnal call to process_srv_queue() in session_free() which
still causes a dead server to consume pending connections from the
backend.
This call was made unconditionnal so that we don't leave unserved
connections in the server queue, for instance connections coming
in with "option persist" which can bypass the server status check.
However, the server must not touch the backend's queue if it is down.
Another fear was that some connections might remain unserved when
the server is using a dynamic maxconn if the number of connections
to the backend is too low. Right now, srv_dynamic_maxconn() ensures
this cannot happen, so the call can remain conditionnal.
The fix consists in allowing a server to process it own queue whatever
its state, but not to touch the backend's queue if it is down. Its
queue should normally be empty when the server is down because it is
redistributed when the server goes down. The only remaining cases are
precisely the persistent connections with "option persist" set, coming
in after the queue has been redispatched. Those ones must still be
processed when a connection terminates.
(cherry picked from commit cd485c4480)
Kai Krueger reported a problem when a server goes down with active
connections. A lot of connections were drained by that server. Kai
did an amazing job at tracking this bug down to the dequeuing
mechanism which forgets to check the server state before allowing
a request to be sent to a server.
The problem occurs more often with long requests, which have a chance
to complete after the server is completely marked down, and to find
requests in the global queue which have not yet been fetched by other
servers.
The fix consists in ensuring that a server is up before sending it
any new request from the queue.
(cherry picked from commit 80b286a064)
(cherry picked from commit 2e5e0d2853f059a1d09dc81fdbbad9fd03124a98)
The dequeuing logic was completely wrong. First, a task was assigned
to all servers to process the queue, but this task was never scheduled
and was only woken up on session free. Second, there was no reservation
of server entries when a task was assigned a server. This means that
as long as the task was not connected to the server, its presence was
not accounted for. This was causing trouble when detecting whether or
not a server had reached maxconn. Third, during a redispatch, a session
could lose its place at the server's and get blocked because another
session at the same moment would have stolen the entry. Fourth, the
redispatch option did not work when maxqueue was reached for a server,
and it was not possible to do so without indefinitely hanging a session.
The root cause of all those problems was the lack of pre-reservation of
connections at the server's, and the lack of tracking of servers during
a redispatch. Everything relied on combinations of flags which could
appear similarly in quite distinct situations.
This patch is a major rework but there was no other solution, as the
internal logic was deeply flawed. The resulting code is cleaner, more
understandable, uses less magics and is overall more robust.
As an added bonus, "option redispatch" now works when maxqueue has
been reached on a server.
The timeout functions were difficult to manipulate because they were
rounding results to the millisecond. Thus, it was difficult to compare
and to check what expired and what did not. Also, the comparison
functions were heavy with multiplies and divides by 1000. Now, all
timeouts are stored in timevals, reducing the number of operations
for updates and leading to cleaner and more efficient code.
As suggested by Markus Elfring, a few "const char *" have replaced
some "char *" declarations where a function is not expected to
modify a value. It does not change the code but it helps detecting
coding errors.
The files are now stored under :
- include/haproxy for the generic includes
- include/types.h for the structures needed within prototypes
- include/proto.h for function prototypes and inline functions
- src/*.c for the C files
Most include files are now covered by LGPL. A last move still needs
to be done to put inline functions under GPL and not LGPL.
Version has been set to 1.3.0 in the code but some control still
needs to be done before releasing.
Willy Tarreau
Willy Tarreau