We used to refrain from calling fd_want_recv() if fd_updt was not allocated
but it's not the right solution as this does not allow the FD to be set.
Instead, let's use the new fd_want_recv_safe() which will update the FD and
create an update entry only if possible. In addition, the equivalent test
before calling fd_stop_recv() was removed as totally useless since there's
not fd_updt creation in this case.
It is not acceptable to suspend an inherited socket because we'd kill
its listening state, making it possibly unrecoverable for future
processes. The situation which can trigger this is when there is an
abns socket in a config and an inherited FD on another listener. Upon
soft reload, the abns fails to bind, a SIGTTOU is sent to the old
process which suspends everything, including the inherited FD, then
the new process can bind and tell the old one to quit. Except that the
new FD was not set back to the listen state, which is detected by
listener_accept() which can pause it. It's only upon second reload
that the FD works again.
The solution is to refrain from suspending such FDs since we don't own
them. And the next process will get them right anyway from its config.
For now only TCP and UDP face this issue so it's better to address this
on a protocol basis
No backport is needed, this is related to the new listeners in 2.3.
Now we define a new sock_accept_iocb() for socket-based stream protocols
and use it as a wrapper for listener_accept() which now takes a listener
and not an FD anymore. This will allow the receiver's I/O cb to be
redefined during registration, and more specifically to get rid of the
hard-coded hacks in protocol_bind_all() made for syslog.
The previous ->accept() callback in the protocol was removed since it
doesn't have anything to do with accept() anymore but is more generic.
A few places where listener_accept() was compared against the FD's IO
callback for debugging purposes on the CLI were updated.
The socket-specific accept() code in listener_accept() has nothing to
do there. Let's move it to sock.c where it can be significantly cleaned
up. It will now directly return an accepted connection and provide a
status code instead of letting listener_accept() deal with various errno
values. Note that this doesn't support the sockpair specific code.
The function is now responsible for dealing with its own receiver's
polling state and calling fd_cant_recv() when facing EAGAIN.
One tiny change from the previous implementation is that the connection's
sockaddr is now allocated before trying accept(), which saves a memcpy()
of the resulting address for each accept at the expense of a cheap
pool_alloc/pool_free on the final accept returning EAGAIN. This still
apparently slightly improves accept performance in microbencharks.
This call was introduced by commit 5ced3e887 ("MINOR: sock: add
sock_accept_conn() to test a listening socket") but is actually quite
confusing because it makes one think the socket will accept a connection
(which is what we want to have in a new function) while it only tells
whether it's configured to accept connections. Let's call it
sock_accepting_conn() instead.
The same change was applied to sockpair which had the same issue.
In issue #894, Coverity suspects uninitialized values for a socket's
address whose family is AF_UNSPEC but it doesn't know that the address
is not used in this case. It's not on a critical path and working around
it is trivial, let's fully declare the address. We're doing it for both
TCP and UDP, because the same principle appears at two places.
Now we introdce a new .rx_listening() function to report if a receiver is
actually a listening socket. The reason for this is to help detect shared
sockets that might have been broken by sibling processes.
Currently the suspend/resume mechanism for listeners only works on Linux
and we resort to a number of tricks involving shutdown+listen+shutdown
to try to detect failures on other operating systems that do not support
it. But on Linux connect(AF_UNSPEC) also works pretty well and is much
cleaner. It still doesn't work on other operating systems but the error
is easier to detect and appears safer. So let's switch to this.
Now we have ->suspend() and ->resume() for listeners at the protocol
level. This means that it now becomes possible for a protocol to redefine
its own way to suspend and resume. The default functions are provided for
TCP, UDP and unix, and they are pass-through to the receiver equivalent
as it used to be till now. Nothing was defined for sockpair since it does
not need to suspend/resume during reloads, hence it will succeed.
The inner part now goes into the protocol and is used to decide how to
unbind a given protocol's listener. The existing code which is able to
also unbind the receiver was provided as a default function that we
currently use everywhere. Some complex listeners like QUIC will use this
to decide how to unbind without impacting existing connections, possibly
by setting up other incoming paths for the traffic.
This is used as a generic way to unbind a receiver at the end of
do_unbind_listener(). This allows to considerably simplify that function
since we can now let the protocol perform the cleanup. The generic code
was moved to sock.c, along with the conditional rx_disable() call. Now
the code also supports that the ->disable() function of the protocol
which acts on the listener performs the close itself and adjusts the
RX_F_BUOND flag accordingly.
These methods will be used to enable/disable accepting new connections
so that listeners do not play with FD directly anymore. Since all the
currently supported protocols work on socket for now, these are identical
to the rx_enable/rx_disable functions. However they were not defined in
sock.c since it's likely that some will quickly start to differ. At the
moment they're not used.
We have to take care of fd_updt before calling fd_{want,stop}_recv()
because it's allocated fairly late in the boot process and some such
functions may be called very early (e.g. to stop a disabled frontend's
listeners).
These methods will be used to enable/disable rx at the receiver level so
that callers don't play with FDs directly anymore. All our protocols use
the generic ones from sock.c at the moment. For now they're not used.
This one undoes ->rx_suspend(), it tries to restore an operational socket.
It was only implemented for TCP since it's the only one we support right
now.
The ->pause method is inappropriate since it doesn't exactly "pause" a
listener but rather temporarily disables it so that it's not visible at
all to let another process take its place. The term "suspend" is more
suitable, since the "pause" is actually what we'll need to apply to the
FULL and LIMITED states which really need to make a pause in the accept
process. And it goes well with the use of the "resume" function that
will also need to be made per-protocol.
Let's rename the function and make it act on the receiver since it's
already what it essentially does, hence the prefix "_rx" to make it
more explicit.
The protocol struct was a bit reordered because it was becoming a real
mess between the parts related to the listeners and those for the
receivers.
Since the listeners were split into receiver+listener, this field ought
to have been renamed because it's confusing. It really links receivers
and not listeners, as most of the time it's used via rx.proto_list!
The nb_listeners field was updated accordingly.
fd_stop_recv() has nothing to do in the generic listener code, it's per
protocol as some don't need it. For instance with abns@ it could even
lead to fd_stop_recv(-1). And later with QUIC we don't want to touch
the fd at all! It used to be that since commit f2cb169487 delegating
fd manipulation to their respective threads it wasn't possible to call
it down there but it's not the case anymore, so let's perform the action
in the protocol-specific code.
In multi-process, the TCP pause is very brittle and we never noticed
it because the error was lost in the upper layers. The problem is that
shutdown() may fail if another process already did it, and will cause
a process to fail to pause.
What we do here in case of error is that we double-check the socket's
state to verify if it's still accepting connections, and if not, we
can conclude that another process already did the job in parallel.
The difficulty here is that we're trying to eliminate false positives
where some OSes will silently report a success on shutdown() while they
don't shut the socket down, hence this dance of shutw/listen/shutr that
only keeps the compatible ones. Probably that a new approach relying on
connect(AF_UNSPEC) would provide better results.
This function is used as a wrapper to set a listener's state everywhere.
We'll use it later to maintain some counters in a consistent state when
switching state so it's capital that all state changes go through it.
No functional change was made beyond calling the wrapper.
When a TCP listener is bound, in the tcp_bind_listener() function, a warning
message may be reported and should be displayed on verbose mode. But the warning
message is actually lost if the socket is successfully bound because we don't
fill the <errmsg> variable in this case.
This patch should fix the issue #863. No backport is needed.
This one will be needed to more accurately select a protocol. It may
differ from the socket type for QUIC, which uses dgram at the socket
layer and provides stream at the control layer. The upper level requests
a control layer only so we need this field.
This removes the following fields from struct protocol that are now
retrieved from the protocol family instead: .sock_family, .sock_addrlen,
.l3_addrlen, .addrcmp, .bind, .get_src, .get_dst.
This also removes the UDP-specific udp{,6}_get_{src,dst}() functions
which were referenced but not used yet. Their goal was only to remap
the original AF_INET* addresses to AF_CUST_UDP*.
Note that .sock_domain is still there as it's used as a selector for
the protocol struct to be used.
We need to specially handle protocol families which regroup common
functions used for a given address family. These functions include
bind(), addrcmp(), get_src() and get_dst() for now. Some fields are
also added about the address family, socket domain (protocol family
passed to the socket() syscall), and address length.
These protocol families are referenced from the protocols but not yet
used.
All protocol's listeners now only take care of themselves and not of
the receiver anymore since that's already being done in proto_bind_all().
Now it finally becomes obvious that UDP doesn't need a listener, as the
only thing it does is to set the listener's state to LI_LISTEN!
This removes all the AF_INET-specific code from tcp_bind_listener()
and now simply relies on sock_inet_bind_listener() to do the same
job. The function was now roughly cut in half and its error path
significantly simplified.
This function collects all the receiver-specific code from both
tcp_bind_listener() and udp_bind_listener() in order to provide a more
generic AF_INET/AF_INET6 socket binding function. For now the API is
not very elegant because some info are still missing from the receiver
while there's no ideal place to fill them except when calling ->listen()
at the protocol level. It looks like some polishing code is needed in
check_config_validity() or somewhere around this in order to finalize
the receivers' setup. The main issue is that listeners and receivers
are created *before* bind_conf options are parsed and that there's no
finishing step to resolve some of them.
The function currently sets up a receiver and subscribes it to the
poller. In an ideal world we wouldn't subscribe it but let the caller
do it after having finished to configure the L4 stuff. The problem is
that the caller would then need to perform an fd_insert() call and to
possibly set the exported flag on the FD while it's not its job. Maybe
an improvement could be to have a separate sock_start_receiver() call
in sock.c.
For now the function is not used but it will soon be. It's already
referenced as tcp and udp's ->bind().
The new RX_O_FOREIGN, RX_O_V6ONLY and RX_O_V4V6 options are now set into
the rx_settings part during the parsing, so that we don't need to adjust
them in each and every listener anymore. We have to keep both v4v6 and
v6only due to the precedence from v6only over v4v6.
It's the receiver's FD that's inherited from the parent process, not
the listener's so the flag must move to the receiver so that appropriate
actions can be taken.
In order to split the receiver from the listener, we'll need to know that
a socket is already bound and ready to receive. We used to do that via
tha LI_O_ASSIGNED state but that's not sufficient anymore since the
receiver might not belong to a listener anymore. The new RX_F_BOUND flag
is used for this.
Some socket settings used to be retrieved via the listener and the
bind_conf. Now instead we use the receiver and its settings whenever
appropriate. This will simplify the removal of the dependency on the
listener.
The receiver is the one which depends on the protocol while the listener
relies on the receiver. Let's move the protocol there. Since there's also
a list element to get back to the listener from the proto list, this list
element (proto_list) was moved as well. For now when scanning protos, we
still see listeners which are linked by their rx.proto_list part.
The listening socket is represented by its file descriptor, which is
generic to all receivers and not just listeners, so it must move to
the rx struct.
It's worth noting that in order to extend receivers and listeners to
other protocols such as QUIC, we'll need other handles than file
descriptors here, and that either a union or a cast to uintptr_t
will have to be used. This was not done yet and the field was
preserved under the name "fd" to avoid adding confusion.
The netns is common to all listeners/receivers and is used to bind the
listening socket so it must be in the receiver settings and not in the
listener. This removes some yet another set of unnecessary loops.
The interface is common to all listeners/receivers and is used to bind
the listening socket so it must be in the receiver settings and not in
the listener. This removes some unnecessary loops.
This code was highly redundant, existing for TCP clients, TCP servers
and UDP servers. Let's move it to sock_inet where it belongs. The new
functions are sock_inet4_make_foreign() and sock_inet6_make_foreign().
This is essentially a merge from tcp_find_compatible_fd() and
uxst_find_compatible_fd() that relies on a listener's address and
compare function and still checks for other variations. For AF_INET6
it compares a few of the listener's bind options. A minor change for
UNIX sockets is that transparent mode, interface and namespace used
to be ignored when trying to pick a previous socket while now if they
are changed, the socket will not be reused. This could be refined but
it's still better this way as there is no more risk of using a
differently bound socket by accident.
Eventually we should not pass a listener there but a set of binding
parameters (address, interface, namespace etc...) which ultimately will
be grouped into a receiver. For now this still doesn't exist so let's
stick to the listener to break dependencies in the rest of the code.
Let's determine it at boot time instead of doing it on first use. It
also saves us from having to keep it thread local. It's been moved to
the new sock_inet_prepare() function, and the variables were renamed
to sock_inet_tcp_maxseg_default and sock_inet6_tcp_maxseg_default.
The v6only_default variable is not specific to TCP but to AF_INET6, so
let's move it to the right file. It's now immediately filled on startup
during the PREPARE stage so that it doesn't have to be tested each time.
The variable's name was changed to sock_inet6_v6only_default.
The function now makes it clear that it's independent on the socket
type and solely relies on the address family. Note that it supports
both IPv4 and IPv6 as we don't seem to need it per-family.
This one is common to the TCPv4 and UDPv4 code, it retrieves the
destination address of a socket, taking care of the possiblity that for
an incoming connection the traffic was possibly redirected. The TCP and
UDP definitions were updated to rely on it and remove duplicated code.
The new addrcmp() protocol member points to the function to be used to
compare two addresses of the same family.
When picking an FD from a previous process, we can now use the address
specific address comparison functions instead of having to rely on a
local implementation. This will help move that code to a more central
place.
The new file sock.c will contain generic code for standard sockets
relying on file descriptors. We currently have way too much duplication
between proto_uxst, proto_tcp, proto_sockpair and proto_udp.
For now only get_src, get_dst and sock_create_server_socket were moved,
and are used where appropriate.
Let's continue the cleanup and get rid of all bind and server keywords
parsers from proto_tcp.c. They're now moved to cfgparse-tcp.c, just as
was done for ssl before 2.2 release. Nothing has changed beyond this.
Now proto_tcp.c is clean and only contains code related to binding and
connecting.
