As specified in the function comment, the function h1_skip_chunk_crlf() must not
change anything and return zero if not enough data are available. This must
include the case where there is no data at all. On this point, it must do the
same that other h1 parsing functions. This bug is made visible since the commit
91f77d599 ("BUG/MINOR: mux-h1: Process input even if the input buffer is
empty").
This patch must be backported to 1.9.
Older compilers (like gcc-3.4) warn about the use of "const" on functions
returning a struct, which makes sense since the return may only be copied :
include/common/htx.h:233: warning: type qualifiers ignored on function return type
Let's simply drop "const" here.
Move the definition of the various _HA_ATOMIC_* macros that use
__atomic_* in the #if GCC_VERSION >= 4.7, not just after it, so that we
can build with older versions of gcc again.
The upgrade is performed when an H2 preface is detected when the first request
on a connection is parsed. The CS is destroyed by setting EOS flag on it. A
special flag is added on the HTX message to warn the HTX analyzers the stream
will be closed because of an upgrade. This way, no error and no log are
emitted. When the mux h1 is released, we create a mux h2, without any CS and
passing the buffer with the unparsed H2 preface.
The flag H1_MF_CLEAN_CONN_HDR has been added to let the H1 parser sanitize
connection headers. It means it will remove all "close" and "keep-alive" values
during the parsing. One noticeable effect is that connection headers may be
unfolded. In practice, this is not a problem because it is not frequent to have
multiple values for the connection headers.
If this flag is set, during the parsing The function
h1_parse_next_connection_header() is called in a loop instead of
h1_parse_conection_header().
No need to backport this patch
When creating a new initcall, don't forget to define the symbols, as it may
not be done automatically and that would lead to undefined symbols.
This should be backported to 1.9.
I found on an (old) AIX 5.1 machine that stdint.h didn't exist while
inttypes.h which is expected to include it does exist and provides the
desired functionalities.
As explained here, stdint being just a subset of inttypes for use in
freestanding environments, it's probably always OK to switch to inttypes
instead:
https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009696799/basedefs/stdint.h.html
Also it's even clearer here in the autoconf doc :
https://www.gnu.org/software/autoconf/manual/autoconf-2.61/html_node/Header-Portability.html
"The C99 standard says that inttypes.h includes stdint.h, so there's
no need to include stdint.h separately in a standard environment.
Some implementations have inttypes.h but not stdint.h (e.g., Solaris
7), but we don't know of any implementation that has stdint.h but not
inttypes.h"
The current initcall implementation relies on dedicated sections (one
section per init stage) to store the initcall descriptors. Then upon
startup, these sections are scanned from beginning to end and all items
found there are called in sequence.
On platforms like AIX or Cygwin it seems difficult to figure the
beginning and end of sections as the linker doesn't seem to provide
the corresponding symbols. In order to replace this, this patch
simply implements an array of single linked (one per init stage)
which are fed using constructors for each register call. These
constructors are declared static, with a name depending on their
line number in the file, in order to avoid name clashes. The final
effect is the same, except that the method is slightly more expensive
in that it explicitly produces code to register these initcalls :
$ size haproxy.sections haproxy.constructor
text data bss dec hex filename
4060312 249176 1457652 5767140 57ffe4 haproxy.sections
4062862 260408 1457652 5780922 5835ba haproxy.constructor
This mechanism is enabled as an alternative to the default one when
build option USE_OBSOLETE_LINKER is set. This option is currently
enabled by default only on AIX and Cygwin, and may be attempted for
any target which fails to build complaining about missing symbols
__start_init_* and/or __stop_init_*.
Once confirmed as a reliable fix, this will likely have to be backported
to 1.9 where AIX and Cygwin do not build anymore.
Older Solaris and AIX versions do not have unsetenv(). This adds a
fairly simple implementation which scans the environment, for use
with those systems. It will simply require to pass the define in
the "DEFINE" macro at build time like this :
DEFINE="-Dunsetenv=my_unsetenv"
http_known_methods, HTTP_100 and HTTP_103 were not declared extern and
as such were multiply defined since they were in http.h. There was
apparently no more side effect but it may depend on the platform and
the linker.
This needs to be backported to 1.9.
Injecting on a saturated listener started to exhibit some deadlocks
again between LIST_POP_LOCKED() and LIST_DEL_LOCKED(). Olivier found
it was due to a leftover from a previous debugging session. This patch
fixes it.
This will have to be backported if the other LIST_*_LOCKED() patches
are backported.
Some packages used to rely on DEFAULT_MAXCONN to set the default global
maxconn value to use regardless of the initial ulimit. The recent changes
made the lowest bound set to 100 so that it is compatible with almost any
environment. Now that DEFAULT_MAXCONN is not needed for anything else, we
can use it for the lowest bound set when maxconn is not configured. This
way it retains its original purpose of setting the default maxconn value
eventhough most of the time the effective value will be higher thanks to
the automatic computation based on "ulimit -n".
This entry was still set to 2000 but never used anymore. The only places
where it appeared was as an alias to SYSTEM_MAXCONN which forces it, so
let's turn these ones to SYSTEM_MAXCONN and remove the default value for
DEFAULT_MAXCONN. SYSTEM_MAXCONN still defines the upper bound however.
Add variants of the HA_ATOMIC* macros, prefixed with a _, that do the
atomic operation with no barrier generated by the compiler. It is expected
the developer adds barriers manually if needed.
When using the new __atomic* API, ask the compiler to generate barriers.
A variant of those functions that don't generate barriers will be added later.
Before that, using HA_ATOMIC* would not generate any barrier, and some parts
of the code should be reviewed and missing barriers should be added.
This should probably be backported to 1.8 and 1.9.
Implement __ha_barrier functions to be used when trying to protect data
modified by atomic operations (except when using HA_ATOMIC_STORE).
On intel, atomic operations either use the LOCK prefix and xchg, and both
atc as full barrier, so there's no need to add an extra barrier.
We already have my_ffsl() to find the lowest bit set in a word, and
this patch implements the search for the highest bit set in a word.
On x86 it uses the bsr instruction and on other architectures it
uses an efficient implementation.
It turns out that we call LIST_DEL+LIST_INIT very frequently and that
the compiler doesn't know what pointers get modified in the e->n->p
and e->p->n dance, so when LIST_INIT() is called, it reloads these
pointers, which is quite a bit of a mess in terms of performance.
This patch adds LIST_DEL_INIT() to perform the two operations at once
using local temporary variables so that the compiler knows these
pointers are left unaffected.
Well, that's becoming embarrassing. Now this fixes commit 4ef6801c
("BUG/MEDIUM: list: correct fix for LIST_POP_LOCKED's removal of last
element") which itself tried to fix commit 285192564. This fix only
works under low contention and was tested with the listener's queue.
With the idle conns it's obvious that it's still wrong since adding
more than one element to the list leaves a LLIST_BUSY pointer into
the list's head. This was visible when accumulating idle connections
in a server's list.
This new version of the fix almost goes back to the original code,
except that since then we addressed issues with expectedly idempotent
operations that were not. Now the code has been verified on paper again
and has survived 300 million connections spread over 4 threads.
This will have to be backported if the commit above is backported.
As seen with Olivier, in the end the fix in commit 285192564 ("BUG/MEDIUM:
list: fix LIST_POP_LOCKED's removal of the last pointer") is wrong,
the code there was right but the bug was triggered by another bug in
LIST_ADDQ_LOCKED() which doesn't properly update the list's head by
inserting in the wrong order.
This will have to be backported if the commit above is backported.
There is a very difficult to reproduce race in the listener's accept
code, which is much easier to reproduce once connection limits are
properly enforced. It's an ABBA lock issue :
- the following functions take l->lock then lq_lock :
disable_listener, pause_listener, listener_full, limit_listener,
do_unbind_listener
- the following ones take lq_lock then l->lock :
resume_listener, dequeue_all_listener
This is because __resume_listener() only takes the listener's lock
and expects to be called with lq_lock held. The problem can easily
happen when listener_full() and limit_listener() are called a lot
while in parallel another thread releases sessions for the same
listener using listener_release() which in turn calls resume_listener().
This scenario is more prevalent in 2.0-dev since the removal of the
accept lock in listener_accept(). However in 1.9 and before, a different
but extremely unlikely scenario can happen :
thread1 thread2
............................ enter listener_accept()
limit_listener()
............................ long pause before taking the lock
session_free()
dequeue_all_listeners()
lock(lq_lock) [1]
............................ try_lock(l->lock) [2]
__resume_listener()
spin_lock(l->lock) =>WAIT[2]
............................ accept()
l->accept()
nbconn==maxconn =>
listener_full()
state==LI_LIMITED =>
lock(lq_lock) =>DEADLOCK[1]!
In practice it is almost impossible to trigger it because it requires
to limit both on the listener's maxconn and the frontend's rate limit,
at the same time, and to release the listener when the connection rate
goes below the limit between poll() returns the FD and the lock is
taken (a few nanoseconds). But maybe with threads competing on the
same core it has more chances to appear.
This patch removes the lq_lock and replaces it with a lockless queue
for the listener's wait queue (well, technically speaking a self-locked
queue) brought by commit a8434ec14 ("MINOR: lists: Implement locked
variations.") and its few subsequent fixes. This relieves us from the
need of the lq_lock and removes the deadlock. It also gets rid of the
distinction between __resume_listener() and resume_listener() since the
only difference was the lq_lock. All listener removals from the list
are now unconditional to avoid races on the state. It's worth noting
that the list used to never be initialized and that it used to work
only thanks to the state tests, so the initialization has now been
added.
This patch must carefully be backported to 1.9 and very likely 1.8.
It is mandatory to be careful about replacing all manipulations of
l->wait_queue, global.listener_queue and p->listener_queue.
These operations previously used to return a "locked" element, which is
a constraint when multiple threads try to delete the same element, because
the second one will block indefinitely. Instead, let's make sure that both
LIST_DEL_LOCKED() and LIST_POP_LOCKED() always reinitialize the element
after deleting it. This ensures that the second thread will immediately
unblock and succeed with the removal. It also secures the pop vs delete
competition that may happen when trying to remove an element that's about
to be dequeued.
Commit a8434ec14 ("MINOR: lists: Implement locked variations.")
introduced locked lists which use the elements pointers as locks
for concurrent operations. Under heavy stress the lists occasionally
fail. The cause is a missing barrier at some points when updating
the list element and the head : nothing prevents the compiler (or
CPU) from updating the list head first before updating the element,
making another thread jump to a wrong location. This patch simply
adds the missing barriers before these two opeations.
This will have to be backported if the commit above is backported.
There was a typo making the last updated pointer be the pre-last element's
prev instead of the last's prev element. It didn't show up during early
tests because the contention is very rare on this one and it's implicitly
recovered when updating the pointers to go to the next element, but it was
clearly visible in the listener_accept() tests by having all threads block
on LIST_POP_LOCKED() with n==p==LLIST_BUSY.
This will have to be backported if commit a8434ec14 ("MINOR: lists:
Implement locked variations.") is backported.
Commit a8434ec14 ("MINOR: lists: Implement locked variations.")
introduced locked lists which use the elements pointers as locks
for concurrent operations. A copy-paste typo in LIST_ADDQ_LOCKED()
causes corruption in the list in case the next pointer is already
held, as it restores the previous pointer into the next one. It
may impact the server pools.
This will have to be backported if the commit above is backported.
Threads have long matured by now, still for most users their usage is
not trivial. It's about time to enable them by default on platforms
where we know the number of CPUs bound. This patch does this, it counts
the number of CPUs the process is bound to upon startup, and enables as
many threads by default. Of course, "nbthread" still overrides this, but
if it's not set the default behaviour is to start one thread per CPU.
The default number of threads is reported in "haproxy -vv". Simply using
"taskset -c" is now enough to adjust this number of threads so that there
is no more need for playing with cpu-map. And thanks to the previous
patches on the listener, the vast majority of configurations will not
need to duplicate "bind" lines with the "process x/y" statement anymore
either, so a simple config will automatically adapt to the number of
processors available.
Function mask_find_rank_bit() returns the bit position in mask <m> of
the nth bit set of rank <r>, between 0 and LONGBITS-1 included, starting
from the left. For example ranks 0,1,2,3 for mask 0x55 will be 6, 4, 2
and 0 respectively. This algorithm is based on a popcount variant and
is described here : https://graphics.stanford.edu/~seander/bithacks.html.
In LIST_DEL_LOCKED(), initialize p2 to NULL, and only attempt to set it back
to its previous value if we had a previous element, and thus p2 is non-NULL.
Implement LIST_ADD_LOCKED(), LIST_ADDQ_LOCKED(), LIST_DEL_LOCKED() and
LIST_POP_LOCKED().
LIST_ADD_LOCKED, LIST_ADDQ_LOCKED and LIST_DEL_LOCKED work the same as
LIST_ADD, LIST_ADDQ and LIST_DEL, except before any manipulation it locks
the relevant elements of the list, so it's safe to manipulate the list
with multiple threads.
LIST_POP_LOCKED() removes the first element from the list, and returns its
data.
This function is useful to parse strings made of unsigned integers
and to allocate a C array of unsigned integers from there.
For instance this function allocates this array { 1, 2, 3, 4, } from
this string: "1.2.3.4".
The function htx_drain() can now be used to drain data from an HTX message.
It will be used by other commits to fix bugs, so it must be backported to 1.9.
1xx responses does not work in HTTP2 when the HTX is enabled. First of all, when
a response is parsed, only one HEADERS frame is expected. So when an interim
response is received, the flag H2_SF_HEADERS_RCVD is set and the next HEADERS
frame (for another interim repsonse or the final one) is parsed as a trailers
one. Then when the response is sent, because an EOM block is found at the end of
the interim HTX response, the ES flag is added on the frame, closing too early
the stream. Here, it is a design problem of the HTX. Iterim responses are
considered as full messages, leading to some ambiguities when HTX messages are
processed. This will not be fixed now, but we need to keep it in mind for future
improvements.
To fix the parsing bug, the flag H2_MSGF_RSP_1XX is added when the response
headers are decoded. When this flag is set, an EOM block is added into the HTX
message, despite the fact that there is no ES flag on the frame. And we don't
set the flag H2_SF_HEADERS_RCVD on the corresponding H2S. So the next HEADERS
frame will not be parsed as a trailers one.
To fix the sending bug, the ES flag is not set on the frame when an interim
response is processed and the flag H2_SF_HEADERS_SENT is not set on the
corresponding H2S.
This patch must be backported to 1.9.
The existing threading flag in the 51Degrees API
(FIFTYONEDEGREES_NO_THREADING) has now been mapped to the HAProxy
threading flag (USE_THREAD), and the 51Degrees module code has been made
thread safe.
In Pattern, the cache is now locked with a spin lock from hathreads.h
using a new lable 'OTHER_LOCK'. The workset pool is now created with the
same size as the number of threads to avoid any time waiting on a
worket.
In Hash Trie, the global device offsets structure is only used in single
threaded operation. Multi threaded operation creates a new offsets
structure in each thread.
For some embedded systems, it's pointless to have 32- or even 64- large
arrays of processes when it's known that much fewer processes will be
used in the worst case. Let's introduce this MAX_PROCS define which
contains the highest number of processes allowed to run at once. It
still defaults to LONGBITS but may be lowered.
We'll call popcount() more often so better use a parallel method
than an iterative one. One optimal design is proposed at the site
below. It requires a fast multiplication though, but even without
it will still be faster than the iterative one, and all relevant
64 bit platforms do have a multiply unit.
https://graphics.stanford.edu/~seander/bithacks.html
When compiling with DEBUG_FAIL_ALLOC, add a new option, tune.fail-alloc,
that gives the percentage of chances an allocation fails.
This is useful to check that allocation failures are always handled
gracefully.
The previous patch clarifies the fact that the htx pointer is never null
along all the code. This test for a null will never match, didn't catch
the pointer 1 before the fix for b_is_null(), but it confuses the compiler
letting it think that any dereferences made to this pointer after this
test could actually mean we're dereferencing a null. Let's now drop this
test. This saves us from having to add impossible tests everywhere to
avoid the warning.
This should be backported to 1.9 if the b_is_null() patch is backported.
Update the comments above htxbuf() and htx_from_buf() to make it clear
that they always return valid htx pointers so that callers know they do
not have to test them. This is only true after the fix on b_is_null()
which was the only known corner case.
This should be backported to 1.9 if the b_is_null() patch is backported.
In b_is_null(), make sure we return 1 if the buffer is waiting for its
allocation, as users assume there's memory allocated if b_is_null() returns
0.
The indirect impact of not having this was that htxbuf() would not match
b_is_null() for a buffer waiting for an allocation, and would thus return
the value 1 for the htx pointer, causing various crashes under low memory
condition.
Note that this patch makes gcc versions 6 and above report two null-deref
warnings in proto_htx.c since htx_is_empty() continues to check for a null
pointer without knowing that this is protected by the test on b_is_null().
This is addressed by the following patches.
This should be backported to 1.9.
Christopher Faulet
Willy Tarreau
Olivier Houchard
Olivier Houchard
Frédéric Lécaille
Ben51Degrees