After much discussion and back-and-forth, we reached the conclusion
that matroska uses convergence_duration for subtitle duration because
a 32bit value isn't large enough to store the duration if sub-micro-second
timebases are used. Matroska may not be the only one that supports these
timebases, but it's certainly the only one that ffmpeg attempts to support
in this way.
The long term solution that we seemed to reach was that if we encounter
a matroska file with a sub-micro-second timebase, we should internally
scale it up to at least micro-second, and then duration can be used
normally. This suggests that on the encode side, we should not allow
generation of files with sub-micro-second timebases, but that's a separate
issue.
That being a non-trivial change, and the subtitle interoperability breakage
being very real, I'm re-submitting this small change for consideration.
In this diff, we make sure that duration is populated by the matroska
demuxer, and that convergence_duration is respected in matroskaenc and
srtenc, but that duration is used otherwise. This ends up being a strict
improvement - pipelines that use convergence duration are unchanged, and
ones that are currently broken due to the duration mismatch will start
working - except for the ones with the extreme timebases, but those were
already broken.
Signed-off-by: Philip Langdale <philipl@overt.org>
Unsurprisingly, if a timing-less subrip decoder is desireable, an
encoder is as well. With this in place, we can move on to remove
the use of the old encoder/decoder with embedded timing and move
all timing handling the (de)muxer where they belong.
Signed-off-by: Philip Langdale <philipl@overt.org>
* qatar/master:
avformat: Drop pointless "format" from container long names
swscale: bury one more piece of inline asm under HAVE_INLINE_ASM.
wv: K&R formatting cosmetics
configure: Add missing descriptions to help output
h264_ps: declare array of colorspace strings on its own line.
fate: amix: specify f32 sample format for comparison
tiny_psnr: support 32-bit float samples
eamad/eatgq/eatqi: call special EA IDCT directly
eamad: remove use of MpegEncContext
mpegvideo: remove unnecessary inclusions of faandct.h
af_asyncts: avoid overflow in out_size with large delta values
af_asyncts: add first_pts option
Conflicts:
configure
libavcodec/eamad.c
libavcodec/h264_ps.c
libavformat/crcenc.c
libavformat/ffmdec.c
libavformat/ffmenc.c
libavformat/framecrcenc.c
libavformat/md5enc.c
libavformat/nutdec.c
libavformat/rawenc.c
libavformat/yuv4mpeg.c
tests/tiny_psnr.c
Merged-by: Michael Niedermayer <michaelni@gmx.at>
This muxer supports CODEC_ID_SRT with the timestamps in the packet data
and CODEC_ID_TEXT with the timestamps in the packet fields.
Makes -scodec copy work from Matroska.
Philip Langdale
Michael Niedermayer
Nicolas George