============== Architecture ============== :term:`Ceph` uniquely delivers **object, block, and file storage** in one unified system. Ceph is highly reliable, easy to manage, and free. The power of Ceph can transform your company's IT infrastructure and your ability to manage vast amounts of data. Ceph delivers extraordinary scalability–thousands of clients accessing petabytes to exabytes of data. A :term:`Ceph Node` leverages commodity hardware and intelligent daemons, and a :term:`Ceph Storage Cluster` accommodates large numbers of nodes, which communicate with each other to replicate and redistribute data dynamically. .. image:: images/stack.png The Ceph Storage Cluster ======================== Ceph provides an infinitely scalable :term:`Ceph Storage Cluster` based upon :abbr:`RADOS (Reliable Autonomic Distributed Object Store)`, which you can read about in `RADOS - A Scalable, Reliable Storage Service for Petabyte-scale Storage Clusters`_. A Ceph Storage Cluster consists of two types of daemons. A :term:`Ceph Monitor` maintains a master copy of the cluster map. A cluster of Ceph monitors ensures high availability should a monitor daemon fail. Storage cluster clients retrieve a copy of the cluster map from the Ceph Monitor. Storage cluster clients and each :term:`Ceph OSD Daemon` use the CRUSH algorithm to efficiently compute information about data location, instead of having to depend on a central lookup table. Ceph's high-level features include providing a native interface to the Ceph Storage Cluster via ``librados``, and a number of service interfaces built on top of ``librados``. .. ditaa:: +---------------+ +---------------+ | OSDs | | Monitors | +---------------+ +---------------+ Storing Data ------------ The Ceph Storage Cluster receives data from :term:`Ceph Clients`--whether it comes through a :term:`Ceph Block Device`, :term:`Ceph Object Storage`, the :term:`Ceph Filesystem` or a custom implementation you create using ``librados``--and it stores the data as objects. Each object corresponds to a file in a filesystem, which is stored on an :term:`Object Storage Device`. Ceph OSD Daemons handle the read/write operations on the storage disks. .. ditaa:: /-----\ +-----+ +-----+ | obj |------>| {d} |------>| {s} | \-----/ +-----+ +-----+ Object File Disk Ceph OSD Daemons store all data as objects in a flat namespace (e.g., no hierarchy of directories). An object has an identifier, binary data, and metadata consisting of a set of name/value pairs. The semantics are completely up to :term:`Ceph Clients`. For example, CephFS uses metadata to store file attributes such as the file owner, created date, last modified date, and so forth. .. ditaa:: /------+------------------------------+----------------\ | ID | Binary Data | Metadata | +------+------------------------------+----------------+ | 1234 | 0101010101010100110101010010 | name1 = value1 | | | 0101100001010100110101010010 | name2 = value2 | | | 0101100001010100110101010010 | nameN = valueN | \------+------------------------------+----------------/ .. note:: An object ID is unique across the entire cluster, not just the local filesystem. .. index:: architecture; high availability, scalability Scalability and High Availability --------------------------------- In traditional architectures, clients talk to a centralized component (e.g., a gateway, broker, API, facade, etc.), which acts as a single point of entry to a complex subsystem. This imposes a limit to both performance and scalability, while introducing a single point of failure (i.e., if the centralized component goes down, the whole system goes down, too). Ceph eliminates the centralized gateway to enable clients to interact with Ceph OSD Daemons directly. Ceph OSD Daemons create object replicas on other Ceph Nodes to ensure data safety and high availabilty. Ceph also uses a cluster of monitors to ensure high availability. To eliminate centralization, Ceph uses an algorithm called CRUSH. .. index:: CRUSH; architecture CRUSH Introduction ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Ceph Clients and Ceph OSD Daemons both use the :abbr:`CRUSH (Controlled Replication Under Scalable Hashing)` algorithm to efficiently compute information about object location, instead of having to depend on a central lookup table. CRUSH provides a better data management mechanism compared to older approaches, and enables massive scale by cleanly distributing the work to all the clients and OSD daemons in the cluster. CRUSH uses intelligent data replication to ensure resiliency, which is better suited to hyper-scale storage. The following sections provide additional details on how CRUSH works. For a detailed discussion of CRUSH, see `CRUSH - Controlled, Scalable, Decentralized Placement of Replicated Data`_. .. index:: architecture; cluster map Cluster Map ~~~~~~~~~~~ Ceph depends upon Ceph Clients and Ceph OSD Daemons having knowledge of the cluster topology, which is inclusive of 5 maps collectively referred to as the "Cluster Map": #. **The Monitor Map:** Contains the cluster ``fsid``, the position, name address and port of each monitor. It also indicates the current epoch, when the map was created, and the last time it changed. To view a monitor map, execute ``ceph mon dump``. #. **The OSD Map:** Contains the cluster ``fsid``, when the map was created and last modified, a list of pools, replica sizes, PG numbers, a list of OSDs and their status (e.g., ``up``, ``in``). To view an OSD map, execute ``ceph osd dump``. #. **The PG Map:** Contains the PG version, its time stamp, the last OSD map epoch, the full ratios, and details on each placement group such as the PG ID, the `Up Set`, the `Acting Set`, the state of the PG (e.g., ``active + clean``), and data usage statistics for each pool. #. **The CRUSH Map:** Contains a list of storage devices, the failure domain hierarchy (e.g., device, host, rack, row, room, etc.), and rules for traversing the hierarchy when storing data. To view a CRUSH map, execute ``ceph osd getcrushmap -o {filename}``; then, decompile it by executing ``crushtool -d {comp-crushmap-filename} -o {decomp-crushmap-filename}``. You can view the decompiled map in a text editor or with ``cat``. #. **The MDS Map:** Contains the current MDS map epoch, when the map was created, and the last time it changed. It also contains the pool for storing metadata, a list of metadata servers, and which metadata servers are ``up`` and ``in``. To view an MDS map, execute ``ceph mds dump``. Each map maintains an iterative history of its operating state changes. Ceph Monitors maintain a master copy of the cluster map including the cluster members, state, changes, and the overall health of the Ceph Storage Cluster. .. index:: high availability; monitor architecture High Availability Monitors ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Before Ceph Clients can read or write data, they must contact a Ceph Monitor to obtain the most recent copy of the cluster map. A Ceph Storage Cluster can operate with a single monitor; however, this introduces a single point of failure (i.e., if the monitor goes down, Ceph Clients cannot read or write data). For added reliability and fault tolerance, Ceph supports a cluster of monitors. In a cluster of monitors, latency and other faults can cause one or more monitors to fall behind the current state of the cluster. For this reason, Ceph must have agreement among various monitor instances regarding the state of the cluster. Ceph always uses a majority of monitors (e.g., 1, 2:3, 3:5, 4:6, etc.) and the `Paxos`_ algorithm to establish a consensus among the monitors about the current state of the cluster. For details on configuring monitors, see the `Monitor Config Reference`_. .. index:: architecture; high availability authentication High Availability Authentication ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Ceph clients can authenticate users with Ceph Monitors, Ceph OSD Daemons and Ceph Metadata Servers, using Ceph's Kerberos-like ``cephx`` protocol. Authenticated users gain authorization to read, write and execute Ceph commands. The Cephx authentication system avoids a single point of failure to ensure scalability and high availability. For details on Cephx and how it differs from Kerberos, see `Ceph Authentication and Authorization`_. .. index:: architecture; smart daemons and scalability Smart Daemons Enable Hyperscale ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ In many clustered architectures, the primary purpose of cluster membership is so that a centralized interface knows which nodes it can access. Then the centralized interface provides services to the client through a double dispatch--which is a **huge** bottleneck at the petabyte-to-exabyte scale. Ceph eliminates the bottleneck: Ceph's OSD Daemons AND Ceph Clients are cluster aware. Like Ceph clients, each Ceph OSD Daemon knows about other Ceph OSD Daemons in the cluster. This enables Ceph OSD Daemons to interact directly with other Ceph OSD Daemons and Ceph monitors. Additionally, it enables Ceph Clients to interact directly with Ceph OSD Daemons. The ability of Ceph Clients, Ceph Monitors and Ceph OSD Daemons to interact with each other means that Ceph OSD Daemons can utilize the CPU and RAM of the Ceph nodes to easily perform tasks that would bog down a centralized server. The ability to leverage this computing power leads to several major benefits: #. **OSDs Service Clients Directly:** Since any network device has a limit to the number of concurrent connections it can support, a centralized system has a low physical limit at high scales. By enabling Ceph Clients to contact Ceph OSD Daemons directly, Ceph increases both performance and total system capacity simultaneously, while removing a single point of failure. Ceph Clients can maintain a session when they need to, and with a particular Ceph OSD Daemon instead of a centralized server. #. **OSD Membership and Status**: Ceph OSD Daemons join a cluster and report on their status. At the lowest level, the Ceph OSD Daemon status is ``up`` or ``down`` reflecting whether or not it is running and able to service Ceph Client requests. If a Ceph OSD Daemon is ``down`` and ``in`` the Ceph Storage Cluster, this status may indicate the failure of the Ceph OSD Daemon. If a Ceph OSD Daemon is not running (e.g., it crashes), the Ceph OSD Daemon cannot notify the Ceph Monitor that it is ``down``. The Ceph Monitor can ping a Ceph OSD Daemon periodically to ensure that it is running. However, Ceph also empowers Ceph OSD Daemons to determine if a neighboring OSD is ``down``, to update the cluster map and to report it to the Ceph monitor(s). This means that Ceph monitors can remain light weight processes. See `Monitoring OSDs`_ and `Heartbeats`_ for additional details. #. **Data Scrubbing:** As part of maintaining data consistency and cleanliness, Ceph OSD Daemons can scrub objects within placement groups. That is, Ceph OSD Daemons can compare object metadata in one placement group with its replicas in placement groups stored on other OSDs. Scrubbing (usually performed daily) catches bugs or filesystem errors. Ceph OSD Daemons also perform deeper scrubbing by comparing data in objects bit-for-bit. Deep scrubbing (usually performed weekly) finds bad sectors on a drive that weren't apparent in a light scrub. See `Data Scrubbing`_ for details on configuring scrubbing. #. **Replication:** Like Ceph Clients, Ceph OSD Daemons use the CRUSH algorithm, but the Ceph OSD Daemon uses it to compute where replicas of objects should be stored (and for rebalancing). In a typical write scenario, a client uses the CRUSH algorithm to compute where to store an object, maps the object to a pool and placement group, then looks at the CRUSH map to identify the primary OSD for the placement group. The client writes the object to the identified placement group in the primary OSD. Then, the primary OSD with its own copy of the CRUSH map identifies the secondary and tertiary OSDs for replication purposes, and replicates the object to the appropriate placement groups in the secondary and tertiary OSDs (as many OSDs as additional replicas), and responds to the client once it has confirmed the object was stored successfully. .. ditaa:: +----------+ | Client | | | +----------+ * ^ Write (1) | | Ack (6) | | v * +-------------+ | Primary OSD | | | +-------------+ * ^ ^ * Write (2) | | | | Write (3) +------+ | | +------+ | +------+ +------+ | | | Ack (4) Ack (5)| | v * * v +---------------+ +---------------+ | Secondary OSD | | Tertiary OSD | | | | | +---------------+ +---------------+ With the ability to perform data replication, Ceph OSD Daemons relieve Ceph clients from that duty, while ensuring high data availability and data safety. Dynamic Cluster Management -------------------------- In the `Scalability and High Availability`_ section, we explained how Ceph uses CRUSH, cluster awareness and intelligent daemons to scale and maintain high availability. Key to Ceph's design is the autonomous, self-healing, and intelligent Ceph OSD Daemon. Let's take a deeper look at how CRUSH works to enable modern cloud storage infrastructures to place data, rebalance the cluster and recover from faults dynamically. .. index:: architecture; pools About Pools ~~~~~~~~~~~ The Ceph storage system supports the notion of 'Pools', which are logical partitions for storing objects. Ceph Clients retrieve a `Cluster Map`_ from a Ceph Monitor, and write objects to pools. The pool's ``size`` or number of replicas, the CRUSH ruleset and the number of placement groups determine how Ceph will place the data. .. ditaa:: +--------+ Retrieves +---------------+ | Client |------------>| Cluster Map | +--------+ +---------------+ | v Writes /-----\ | obj | \-----/ | To v +--------+ +---------------+ | Pool |---------->| CRUSH Ruleset | +--------+ Selects +---------------+ Pools set at least the following parameters: - Ownership/Access to Objects - The Number of Placement Groups, and - The CRUSH Ruleset to Use. See `Set Pool Values`_ for details. .. index: architecture; placement group mapping Mapping PGs to OSDs ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Each pool has a number of placement groups. CRUSH maps PGs to OSDs dynamically. When a Ceph Client stores objects, CRUSH will map each object to a placement group. Mapping objects to placement groups creates a layer of indirection between the Ceph OSD Daemon and the Ceph Client. The Ceph Storage Cluster must be able to grow (or shrink) and rebalance where it stores objects dynamically. If the Ceph Client "knew" which Ceph OSD Daemon had which object, that would create a tight coupling between the Ceph Client and the Ceph OSD Daemon. Instead, the CRUSH algorithm maps each object to a placement group and then maps each placement group to one or more Ceph OSD Daemons. This layer of indirection allows Ceph to rebalance dynamically when new Ceph OSD Daemons and the underlying OSD devices come online. The following diagram depicts how CRUSH maps objects to placement groups, and placement groups to OSDs. .. ditaa:: /-----\ /-----\ /-----\ /-----\ /-----\ | obj | | obj | | obj | | obj | | obj | \-----/ \-----/ \-----/ \-----/ \-----/ | | | | | +--------+--------+ +---+----+ | | v v +-----------------------+ +-----------------------+ | Placement Group #1 | | Placement Group #2 | | | | | +-----------------------+ +-----------------------+ | | | +-----------------------+---+ +------+------+-------------+ | | | | | v v v v /----------\ /----------\ /----------\ /----------\ | | | | | | | | | OSD #1 | | OSD #2 | | OSD #3 | | OSD #4 | | | | | | | | | \----------/ \----------/ \----------/ \----------/ With a copy of the cluster map and the CRUSH algorithm, the client can compute exactly which OSD to use when reading or writing a particular object. .. index:: architecture; calculating PG IDs Calculating PG IDs ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ When a Ceph Client binds to a Ceph Monitor, it retrieves the latest copy of the `Cluster Map`_. With the cluster map, the client knows about all of the monitors, OSDs, and metadata servers in the cluster. **However, it doesn't know anything about object locations.** .. epigraph:: Object locations get computed. The only input required by the client is the object ID and the pool. It's simple: Ceph stores data in named pools (e.g., "liverpool"). When a client wants to store a named object (e.g., "john," "paul," "george," "ringo", etc.) it calculates a placement group using the object name, a hash code, the number of PGs in the pool and the pool name. Ceph clients use the following steps to compute PG IDs. #. The client inputs the pool ID and the object ID. (e.g., pool = "liverpool" and object-id = "john") #. Ceph takes the object ID and hashes it. #. Ceph calculates the hash modulo the number of PGs. (e.g., ``58``) to get a PG ID. #. Ceph gets the pool ID given the pool name (e.g., "liverpool" = ``4``) #. Ceph prepends the pool ID to the PG ID (e.g., ``4.58``). Computing object locations is much faster than performing object location query over a chatty session. The :abbr:`CRUSH (Controlled Replication Under Scalable Hashing)` algorithm allows a client to compute where objects *should* be stored, and enables the client to contact the primary OSD to store or retrieve the objects. .. index:: architecture; PG Peering Peering and Sets ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ In previous sections, we noted that Ceph OSD Daemons check each others heartbeats and report back to the Ceph Monitor. Another thing Ceph OSD daemons do is called 'peering', which is the process of bringing all of the OSDs that store a Placement Group (PG) into agreement about the state of all of the objects (and their metadata) in that PG. In fact, Ceph OSD Daemons `Report Peering Failure`_ to the Ceph Monitors. Peering issues usually resolve themselves; however, if the problem persists, you may need to refer to the `Troubleshooting Peering Failure`_ section. .. Note:: Agreeing on the state does not mean that the PGs have the latest contents. The Ceph Storage Cluster was designed to store at least two copies of an object (i.e., ``size = 2``), which is the minimum requirement for data safety. For high availability, a Ceph Storage Cluster should store more than two copies of an object (e.g., ``size = 3`` and ``min size = 2``) so that it can continue to run in a ``degraded`` state while maintaining data safety. Referring back to the diagram in `Smart Daemons Enable Hyperscale`_, we do not name the Ceph OSD Daemons specifically (e.g., ``osd.0``, ``osd.1``, etc.), but rather refer to them as *Primary*, *Secondary*, and so forth. By convention, the *Primary* is the first OSD in the *Acting Set*, and is responsible for coordinating the peering process for each placement group where it acts as the *Primary*, and is the **ONLY** OSD that that will accept client-initiated writes to objects for a given placement group where it acts as the *Primary*. When a series of OSDs are responsible for a placement group, that series of OSDs, we refer to them as an *Acting Set*. An *Acting Set* may refer to the Ceph OSD Daemons that are currently responsible for the placement group, or the Ceph OSD Daemons that were responsible for a particular placement group as of some epoch. The Ceph OSD daemons that are part of an *Acting Set* may not always be ``up``. When an OSD in the *Acting Set* is ``up``, it is part of the *Up Set*. The *Up Set* is an important distinction, because Ceph can remap PGs to other Ceph OSD Daemons when an OSD fails. .. note:: In an *Acting Set* for a PG containing ``osd.25``, ``osd.32`` and ``osd.61``, the first OSD, ``osd.25``, is the *Primary*. If that OSD fails, the Secondary, ``osd.32``, becomes the *Primary*, and ``osd.25`` will be removed from the *Up Set*. .. index:: architecture; Rebalancing Rebalancing ~~~~~~~~~~~ When you add a Ceph OSD Daemon to a Ceph Storage Cluster, the cluster map gets updated with the new OSD. Referring back to `Calculating PG IDs`_, this changes the cluster map. Consequently, it changes object placement, because it changes an input for the calculations. The following diagram depicts the rebalancing process (albeit rather crudely, since it is substantially less impactful with large clusters) where some, but not all of the PGs migrate from existing OSDs (OSD 1, and OSD 2) to the new OSD (OSD 3). Even when rebalancing, CRUSH is stable. Many of the placement groups remain in their original configuration, and each OSD gets some added capacity, so there are no load spikes on the new OSD after rebalancing is complete. .. ditaa:: +--------+ +--------+ Before | OSD 1 | | OSD 2 | +--------+ +--------+ | PG #1 | | PG #6 | | PG #2 | | PG #7 | | PG #3 | | PG #8 | | PG #4 | | PG #9 | | PG #5 | | PG #10 | +--------+ +--------+ +--------+ +--------+ +--------+ After | OSD 1 | | OSD 2 | | OSD 3 | +--------+ +--------+ +--------+ | PG #1 | | PG #7 | | PG #3 | | PG #2 | | PG #8 | | PG #6 | | PG #4 | | PG #10 | | PG #9 | | PG #5 | | | | | | | | | | | +--------+ +--------+ +--------+ .. index:: architecture; Data Scrubbing Data Consistency ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ As part of maintaining data consistency and cleanliness, Ceph OSDs can also scrub objects within placement groups. That is, Ceph OSDs can compare object metadata in one placement group with its replicas in placement groups stored in other OSDs. Scrubbing (usually performed daily) catches OSD bugs or filesystem errors. OSDs can also perform deeper scrubbing by comparing data in objects bit-for-bit. Deep scrubbing (usually performed weekly) finds bad sectors on a disk that weren't apparent in a light scrub. See `Data Scrubbing`_ for details on configuring scrubbing. .. index:: erasure coding Erasure Coding -------------- An erasure coded pool stores each object as ``K+M`` chunks. It is divided into ``K`` data chunks and ``M`` coding chunks. The pool is configured to have a size of ``K+M`` so that each chunk is stored in an OSD in the acting set. The rank of the chunk is stored as an attribute of the object. For instance an erasure coded pool is created to use five OSDs (``K+M = 5``) and sustain the loss of two of them (``M = 2``). Reading and Writing Encoded Chunks ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ When the object **NYAN** containing ``ABCDEFGHI`` is written to the pool, the erasure encoding function splits the content into three data chunks simply by dividing the content in three: the first contains ``ABC``, the second ``DEF`` and the last ``GHI``. The content will be padded if the content length is not a multiple of ``K``. The function also creates two coding chunks: the fourth with ``YXY`` and the fifth with ``GQC``. Each chunk is stored in an OSD in the acting set. The chunks are stored in objects that have the same name (**NYAN**) but reside on different OSDs. The order in which the chunks were created must be preserved and is stored as an attribute of the object (``shard_t``), in addition to its name. Chunk 1 contains ``ABC`` and is stored on **OSD5** while chunk 4 contains ``YXY`` and is stored on **OSD3**. .. ditaa:: +-------------------+ name | NYAN | +-------------------+ content | ABCDEFGHI | +--------+----------+ | | v +------+------+ +---------------+ encode(3,2) +-----------+ | +--+--+---+---+ | | | | | | | +-------+ | +-----+ | | | | | | +--v---+ +--v---+ +--v---+ +--v---+ +--v---+ name | NYAN | | NYAN | | NYAN | | NYAN | | NYAN | +------+ +------+ +------+ +------+ +------+ shard | 1 | | 2 | | 3 | | 4 | | 5 | +------+ +------+ +------+ +------+ +------+ content | ABC | | DEF | | GHI | | YXY | | QGC | +--+---+ +--+---+ +--+---+ +--+---+ +--+---+ | | | | | | | v | | | | +--+---+ | | | | | OSD1 | | | | | +------+ | | | | | | | | +------+ | | | +------>| OSD2 | | | | +------+ | | | | | | +------+ | | | | OSD3 |<----+ | | +------+ | | | | +------+ | | | OSD4 |<--------------+ | +------+ | | +------+ +----------------->| OSD5 | +------+ When the object **NYAN** is read from the erasure coded pool, the decoding function reads three chunks: chunk 1 containing ``ABC``, chunk 3 containing ``GHI`` and chunk 4 containing ``YXY``. Then, it rebuilds the original content of the object ``ABCDEFGHI``. The decoding function is informed that the chunks 2 and 5 are missing (they are called 'erasures'). The chunk 5 could not be read because the **OSD4** is out. The decoding function can be called as soon as three chunks are read: **OSD2** was the slowest and its chunk was not taken into account. .. ditaa:: +-------------------+ name | NYAN | +-------------------+ content | ABCDEFGHI | +---------+---------+ ^ | | +-------+-------+ | decode(3,2) | +------------->+ erasures 2,5 +<-+ | | | | | +-------+-------+ | | ^ | | | | | | | +--+---+ +------+ +---+--+ +---+--+ name | NYAN | | NYAN | | NYAN | | NYAN | +------+ +------+ +------+ +------+ shard | 1 | | 2 | | 3 | | 4 | +------+ +------+ +------+ +------+ content | ABC | | DEF | | GHI | | YXY | +--+---+ +--+---+ +--+---+ +--+---+ ^ . ^ ^ | TOO . | | | SLOW . +--+---+ | | ^ | OSD1 | | | | +------+ | | | | | | +------+ | | +-------| OSD2 | | | +------+ | | | | +------+ | | | OSD3 |------+ | +------+ | | +------+ | | OSD4 | OUT | +------+ | | +------+ +------------------| OSD5 | +------+ Interrupted Full Writes ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ In an erasure coded pool, the primary OSD in the up set receives all write operations. It is responsible for encoding the payload into ``K+M`` chunks and sends them to the other OSDs. It is also responsible for maintaining an authoritative version of the placement group logs. In the following diagram, an erasure coded placement group has been created with ``K = 2 + M = 1`` and is supported by three OSDs, two for ``K`` and one for ``M``. The acting set of the placement group is made of **OSD 1**, **OSD 2** and **OSD 3**. An object has been encoded and stored in the OSDs : the chunk ``D1v1`` (i.e. Data chunk number 1, version 1) is on **OSD 1**, ``D2v1`` on **OSD 2** and ``C1v1`` (i.e. Coding chunk number 1, version 1) on **OSD 3**. The placement group logs on each OSD are identical (i.e. ``1,1`` for epoch 1, version 1). .. ditaa:: Primary OSD +-------------+ | OSD 1 | +-------------+ | log | Write Full | | | +----+ |<------------+ Ceph Client | | |D1v1| 1,1 | v1 | | | +----+ | +-------------+ +------+------+ | | | +-------------+ | | OSD 2 | | | log | +--------->+ +----+ | | | |D2v1| 1,1 | | | +----+ | | +-------------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 3 | | | log | +--------->| +----+ | | |C1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +-------------+ **OSD 1** is the primary and receives a **WRITE FULL** from a client, which means the payload is to replace the object entirely instead of overwriting a portion of it. Version 2 (v2) of the object is created to override version 1 (v1). **OSD 1** encodes the payload into three chunks: ``D1v2`` (i.e. Data chunk number 1 version 2) will be on **OSD 1**, ``D2v2`` on **OSD 2** and ``C1v2`` (i.e. Coding chunk number 1 version 2) on **OSD 3**. Each chunk is sent to the target OSD, including the primary OSD which is responsible for storing chunks in addition to handling write operations and maintaining an authoritative version of the placement group logs. When an OSD receives the message instructing it to write the chunk, it also creates a new entry in the placement group logs to reflect the change. For instance, as soon as **OSD 3** stores ``C1v2``, it adds the entry ``1,2`` ( i.e. epoch 1, version 2 ) to its logs. Because the OSDs work asynchronously, some chunks may still be in flight ( such as ``D2v2`` ) while others are acknowledged and on disk ( such as ``C1v1`` and ``D1v1``). .. ditaa:: Primary OSD +-------------+ | OSD 1 | | log | | +----+ | +-------------+ | |D1v2| 1,2 | Write Full | | | +----+ +<------------+ Ceph Client | | | v2 | | | +----+ | +-------------+ | |D1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +------+------+ | | | +------+------+ | | OSD 2 | | +------+ | log | +->| D2v2 | | +----+ | | +------+ | |D2v1| 1,1 | | | +----+ | | +-------------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 3 | | | log | | | +----+ | | | |C1v2| 1,2 | +---------->+ +----+ | | | | +----+ | | |C1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +-------------+ If all goes well, the chunks are acknowledged on each OSD in the acting set and the logs' ``last_complete`` pointer can move from ``1,1`` to ``1,2``. .. ditaa:: Primary OSD +-------------+ | OSD 1 | | log | | +----+ | +-------------+ | |D1v2| 1,2 | Write Full | | | +----+ +<------------+ Ceph Client | | | v2 | | | +----+ | +-------------+ | |D1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +------+------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 2 | | | log | | | +----+ | | | |D2v2| 1,2 | +---------->+ +----+ | | | | | | +----+ | | | |D2v1| 1,1 | | | +----+ | | +-------------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 3 | | | log | | | +----+ | | | |C1v2| 1,2 | +---------->+ +----+ | | | | +----+ | | |C1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +-------------+ Finally, the files used to store the chunks of the previous version of the object can be removed: ``D1v1`` on **OSD 1**, ``D2v1`` on **OSD 2** and ``C1v1`` on **OSD 3**. .. ditaa:: Primary OSD +-------------+ | OSD 1 | +-------------+ | log | Write Full | | | +----+ |<------------+ Ceph Client | | |D1v2| 1,1 | v2 | | | +----+ | +-------------+ +------+------+ | | | +-------------+ | | OSD 2 | | | log | +--------->+ +----+ | | | |D2v2| 1,1 | | | +----+ | | +-------------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 3 | | | log | +--------->| +----+ | | |C1v2| 1,1 | | +----+ | +-------------+ But accidents happen. If **OSD 1** goes down while ``D2v2`` is still in flight, the object's version 2 is partially written: **OSD 3** has one chunk but that is no not enough to recover. It lost two chunks: ``D1v2`` and ``D2v2`` and the erasure coding parameters ``K = 2 + M = 1`` require that at least two chunks are available to rebuild the third. **OSD 4** becomes the new primary and finds that the ``last_complete`` log entry (i.e., all objects before this entry were known to be available on all OSDs in the previous acting set ) is ``1,1`` and that will be the head of the new authoritative log. .. ditaa:: +-------------+ | OSD 1 | | (down) | | c333 | +------+------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 2 | | | log | | | +----+ | +---------->+ |D1v2| 1,2 | | | +----+ | | | | | +-------------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 3 | | | log | | | +----+ | | | |C1v2| 1,2 | +---------->+ +----+ | | | | +----+ | | |C1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +-------------+ Primary OSD +-------------+ | OSD 4 | | log | | | | 1,1 | | | +------+------+ The log entry 1,2 found on **OSD 3** is divergent from the new authoritative log provided by **OSD 4**: it is discarded and the file containing the ``C1v2`` chunk is removed. The ``D1v1`` chunk is rebuilt with the ``decode`` function of the erasure coding library during scrubbing and stored on the new primary **OSD 4**. .. ditaa:: Primary OSD +-------------+ | OSD 4 | | log | | +----+ | | |D1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +------+------+ ^ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 2 | | | log | +----------+ +----+ | | | |D2v1| 1,1 | | | +----+ | | +-------------+ | | +-------------+ | | OSD 3 | | | log | +----------| +----+ | | |C1v1| 1,1 | | +----+ | +-------------+ +-------------+ | OSD 1 | | (down) | | c333 | +-------------+ See `Erasure Code Notes`_ for additional details. Cache Tiering ------------- A cache tier provides Ceph Clients with better I/O performance for a subset of the data stored in a backing storage tier. Cache tiering involves creating a pool of relatively fast/expensive storage devices (e.g., solid state drives) configured to act as a cache tier, and a backing pool of either erasure-coded or relatively slower/cheaper devices configured to act as an economical storage tier. The Ceph objecter handles where to place the objects and the tiering agent determines when to flush objects from the cache to the backing storage tier. So the cache tier and the backing storage tier are completely transparent to Ceph clients. .. ditaa:: +-------------+ | Ceph Client | +------+------+ ^ Tiering is | Transparent | Faster I/O to Ceph | +---------------+ Client Ops | | | | +----->+ Cache Tier | | | | | | | +-----+---+-----+ | | | ^ v v | | Active Data in Cache Tier +------+----+--+ | | | Objecter | | | +-----------+--+ | | ^ | | Inactive Data in Storage Tier | v | | +-----+---+-----+ | | | +----->| Storage Tier | | | +---------------+ Slower I/O See `Cache Tiering`_ for additional details. .. index:: Extensibility, Ceph Classes Extending Ceph -------------- You can extend Ceph by creating shared object classes called 'Ceph Classes'. Ceph loads ``.so`` classes stored in the ``osd class dir`` directory dynamically (i.e., ``$libdir/rados-classes`` by default). When you implement a class, you can create new object methods that have the ability to call the native methods in the Ceph Object Store, or other class methods you incorporate via libraries or create yourself. On writes, Ceph Classes can call native or class methods, perform any series of operations on the inbound data and generate a resulting write transaction that Ceph will apply atomically. On reads, Ceph Classes can call native or class methods, perform any series of operations on the outbound data and return the data to the client. .. topic:: Ceph Class Example A Ceph class for a content management system that presents pictures of a particular size and aspect ratio could take an inbound bitmap image, crop it to a particular aspect ratio, resize it and embed an invisible copyright or watermark to help protect the intellectual property; then, save the resulting bitmap image to the object store. See ``src/objclass/objclass.h``, ``src/fooclass.cc`` and ``src/barclass`` for exemplary implementations. Summary ------- Ceph Storage Clusters are dynamic--like a living organism. Whereas, many storage appliances do not fully utilize the CPU and RAM of a typical commodity server, Ceph does. From heartbeats, to peering, to rebalancing the cluster or recovering from faults, Ceph offloads work from clients (and from a centralized gateway which doesn't exist in the Ceph architecture) and uses the computing power of the OSDs to perform the work. When referring to `Hardware Recommendations`_ and the `Network Config Reference`_, be cognizant of the foregoing concepts to understand how Ceph utilizes computing resources. .. index:: Ceph Protocol, librados Ceph Protocol ============= Ceph Clients use the native protocol for interacting with the Ceph Storage Cluster. Ceph packages this functionality into the ``librados`` library so that you can create your own custom Ceph Clients. The following diagram depicts the basic architecture. .. ditaa:: +---------------------------------+ | Ceph Storage Cluster Protocol | | (librados) | +---------------------------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ | OSDs | | Monitors | +---------------+ +---------------+ Native Protocol and ``librados`` -------------------------------- Modern applications need a simple object storage interface with asynchronous communication capability. The Ceph Storage Cluster provides a simple object storage interface with asynchronous communication capability. The interface provides direct, parallel access to objects throughout the cluster. - Pool Operations - Snapshots and Copy-on-write Cloning - Read/Write Objects - Create or Remove - Entire Object or Byte Range - Append or Truncate - Create/Set/Get/Remove XATTRs - Create/Set/Get/Remove Key/Value Pairs - Compound operations and dual-ack semantics - Object Classes .. index:: architecture; watch/notify Object Watch/Notify ------------------- A client can register a persistent interest with an object and keep a session to the primary OSD open. The client can send a notification message and payload to all watchers and receive notification when the watchers receive the notification. This enables a client to use any object a synchronization/communication channel. .. ditaa:: +----------+ +----------+ +----------+ +---------------+ | Client 1 | | Client 2 | | Client 3 | | OSD:Object ID | +----------+ +----------+ +----------+ +---------------+ | | | | | | | | | | Watch Object | | |--------------------------------------------------->| | | | | |<---------------------------------------------------| | | Ack/Commit | | | | | | | | Watch Object | | | |---------------------------------->| | | | | | |<----------------------------------| | | Ack/Commit | | | | | Watch Object | | | |----------------->| | | | | | | |<-----------------| | | | Ack/Commit | | | Notify | | |--------------------------------------------------->| | | | | |<---------------------------------------------------| | | Notify | | | | | | | |<----------------------------------| | | Notify | | | | |<-----------------| | | | Notify | | | Ack | | |----------------+---------------------------------->| | | | | | | Ack | | | +---------------------------------->| | | | | | | | Ack | | | |----------------->| | | | | |<---------------+----------------+------------------| | Complete .. index:: architecture; Striping Data Striping ------------- Storage devices have throughput limitations, which impact performance and scalability. So storage systems often support `striping`_--storing sequential pieces of information across across multiple storage devices--to increase throughput and performance. The most common form of data striping comes from `RAID`_. The RAID type most similar to Ceph's striping is `RAID 0`_, or a 'striped volume.' Ceph's striping offers the throughput of RAID 0 striping, the reliability of n-way RAID mirroring and faster recovery. Ceph provides three types of clients: Ceph Block Device, Ceph Filesystem, and Ceph Object Storage. A Ceph Client converts its data from the representation format it provides to its users (a block device image, RESTful objects, CephFS filesystem directories) into objects for storage in the Ceph Storage Cluster. .. tip:: The objects Ceph stores in the Ceph Storage Cluster are not striped. Ceph Object Storage, Ceph Block Device, and the Ceph Filesystem stripe their data over multiple Ceph Storage Cluster objects. Ceph Clients that write directly to the Ceph Storage Cluster via ``librados`` must perform the the striping (and parallel I/O) for themselves to obtain these benefits. The simplest Ceph striping format involves a stripe count of 1 object. Ceph Clients write stripe units to a Ceph Storage Cluster object until the object is at its maximum capacity, and then create another object for additional stripes of data. The simplest form of striping may be sufficient for small block device images, S3 or Swift objects and CephFS files. However, this simple form doesn't take maximum advantage of Ceph's ability to distribute data across placement groups, and consequently doesn't improve performance very much. The following diagram depicts the simplest form of striping: .. ditaa:: +---------------+ | Client Data | | Format | | cCCC | +---------------+ | +--------+-------+ | | v v /-----------\ /-----------\ | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | Object 0 | | Object 1 | +-----------+ +-----------+ | stripe | | stripe | | unit 1 | | unit 5 | +-----------+ +-----------+ | stripe | | stripe | | unit 2 | | unit 6 | +-----------+ +-----------+ | stripe | | stripe | | unit 3 | | unit 7 | +-----------+ +-----------+ | stripe | | stripe | | unit 4 | | unit 8 | +-----------+ +-----------+ | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | Object 0 | | Object 1 | \-----------/ \-----------/ If you anticipate large images sizes, large S3 or Swift objects (e.g., video), or large CephFS directories, you may see considerable read/write performance improvements by striping client data over multiple objects within an object set. Significant write performance occurs when the client writes the stripe units to their corresponding objects in parallel. Since objects get mapped to different placement groups and further mapped to different OSDs, each write occurs in parallel at the maximum write speed. A write to a single disk would be limited by the head movement (e.g. 6ms per seek) and bandwidth of that one device (e.g. 100MB/s). By spreading that write over multiple objects (which map to different placement groups and OSDs) Ceph can reduce the number of seeks per drive and combine the throughput of multiple drives to achieve much faster write (or read) speeds. .. note:: Striping is independent of object replicas. Since CRUSH replicates objects across OSDs, stripes get replicated automatically. In the following diagram, client data gets striped across an object set (``object set 1`` in the following diagram) consisting of 4 objects, where the first stripe unit is ``stripe unit 0`` in ``object 0``, and the fourth stripe unit is ``stripe unit 3`` in ``object 3``. After writing the fourth stripe, the client determines if the object set is full. If the object set is not full, the client begins writing a stripe to the first object again (``object 0`` in the following diagram). If the object set is full, the client creates a new object set (``object set 2`` in the following diagram), and begins writing to the first stripe (``stripe unit 16``) in the first object in the new object set (``object 4`` in the diagram below). .. ditaa:: +---------------+ | Client Data | | Format | | cCCC | +---------------+ | +-----------------+--------+--------+-----------------+ | | | | +--\ v v v v | /-----------\ /-----------\ /-----------\ /-----------\ | | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | | Object 0 | | Object 1 | | Object 2 | | Object 3 | | +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | | unit 0 | | unit 1 | | unit 2 | | unit 3 | | +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | +-\ | unit 4 | | unit 5 | | unit 6 | | unit 7 | | Object +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +- Set | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | 1 | unit 8 | | unit 9 | | unit 10 | | unit 11 | +-/ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | | unit 12 | | unit 13 | | unit 14 | | unit 15 | | +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | | Object 0 | | Object 1 | | Object 2 | | Object 3 | | \-----------/ \-----------/ \-----------/ \-----------/ | | +--/ +--\ | /-----------\ /-----------\ /-----------\ /-----------\ | | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | Begin cCCC| | | Object 4 | | Object 5 | | Object 6 | | Object 7 | | +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | | unit 16 | | unit 17 | | unit 18 | | unit 19 | | +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | +-\ | unit 20 | | unit 21 | | unit 22 | | unit 23 | | Object +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +- Set | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | 2 | unit 24 | | unit 25 | | unit 26 | | unit 27 | +-/ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | stripe | | | unit 28 | | unit 29 | | unit 30 | | unit 31 | | +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ +-----------+ | | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | End cCCC | | | Object 4 | | Object 5 | | Object 6 | | Object 7 | | \-----------/ \-----------/ \-----------/ \-----------/ | | +--/ Three important variables determine how Ceph stripes data: - **Object Size:** Objects in the Ceph Storage Cluster have a maximum configurable size (e.g., 2MB, 4MB, etc.). The object size should be large enough to accommodate many stripe units, and should be a multiple of the stripe unit. - **Stripe Width:** Stripes have a configurable unit size (e.g., 64kb). The Ceph Client divides the data it will write to objects into equally sized stripe units, except for the last stripe unit. A stripe width, should be a fraction of the Object Size so that an object may contain many stripe units. - **Stripe Count:** The Ceph Client writes a sequence of stripe units over a series of objects determined by the stripe count. The series of objects is called an object set. After the Ceph Client writes to the last object in the object set, it returns to the first object in the object set. .. important:: Test the performance of your striping configuration before putting your cluster into production. You CANNOT change these striping parameters after you stripe the data and write it to objects. Once the Ceph Client has striped data to stripe units and mapped the stripe units to objects, Ceph's CRUSH algorithm maps the objects to placement groups, and the placement groups to Ceph OSD Daemons before the objects are stored as files on a storage disk. .. note:: Since a client writes to a single pool, all data striped into objects get mapped to placement groups in the same pool. So they use the same CRUSH map and the same access controls. .. index:: architecture; Ceph Clients Ceph Clients ============ Ceph Clients include a number of service interfaces. These include: - **Block Devices:** The :term:`Ceph Block Device` (a.k.a., RBD) service provides resizable, thin-provisioned block devices with snapshotting and cloning. Ceph stripes a block device across the cluster for high performance. Ceph supports both kernel objects (KO) and a QEMU hypervisor that uses ``librbd`` directly--avoiding the kernel object overhead for virtualized systems. - **Object Storage:** The :term:`Ceph Object Storage` (a.k.a., RGW) service provides RESTful APIs with interfaces that are compatible with Amazon S3 and OpenStack Swift. - **Filesystem**: The :term:`Ceph Filesystem` (CephFS) service provides a POSIX compliant filesystem usable with ``mount`` or as a filesytem in user space (FUSE). Ceph can run additional instances of OSDs, MDSs, and monitors for scalability and high availability. The following diagram depicts the high-level architecture. .. ditaa:: +--------------+ +----------------+ +-------------+ | Block Device | | Object Storage | | Ceph FS | +--------------+ +----------------+ +-------------+ +--------------+ +----------------+ +-------------+ | librbd | | librgw | | libcephfs | +--------------+ +----------------+ +-------------+ +---------------------------------------------------+ | Ceph Storage Cluster Protocol (librados) | +---------------------------------------------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ | OSDs | | MDSs | | Monitors | +---------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ .. index:: architecture; Ceph Object Storage Ceph Object Storage ------------------- The Ceph Object Storage daemon, ``radosgw``, is a FastCGI service that provides a RESTful_ HTTP API to store objects and metadata. It layers on top of the Ceph Storage Cluster with its own data formats, and maintains its own user database, authentication, and access control. The RADOS Gateway uses a unified namespace, which means you can use either the OpenStack Swift-compatible API or the Amazon S3-compatible API. For example, you can write data using the S3-compatible API with one application and then read data using the Swift-compatible API with another application. .. topic:: S3/Swift Objects and Store Cluster Objects Compared Ceph's Object Storage uses the term *object* to describe the data it stores. S3 and Swift objects are not the same as the objects that Ceph writes to the Ceph Storage Cluster. Ceph Object Storage objects are mapped to Ceph Storage Cluster objects. The S3 and Swift objects do not necessarily correspond in a 1:1 manner with an object stored in the storage cluster. It is possible for an S3 or Swift object to map to multiple Ceph objects. See `Ceph Object Storage`_ for details. .. index:: Ceph Block Device; block device; RBD; Rados Block Device Ceph Block Device ----------------- A Ceph Block Device stripes a block device image over multiple objects in the Ceph Storage Cluster, where each object gets mapped to a placement group and distributed, and the placement groups are spread across separate ``ceph-osd`` daemons throughout the cluster. .. important:: Striping allows RBD block devices to perform better than a single server could! Thin-provisioned snapshottable Ceph Block Devices are an attractive option for virtualization and cloud computing. In virtual machine scenarios, people typically deploy a Ceph Block Device with the ``rbd`` network storage driver in Qemu/KVM, where the host machine uses ``librbd`` to provide a block device service to the guest. Many cloud computing stacks use ``libvirt`` to integrate with hypervisors. You can use thin-provisioned Ceph Block Devices with Qemu and ``libvirt`` to support OpenStack and CloudStack among other solutions. While we do not provide ``librbd`` support with other hypervisors at this time, you may also use Ceph Block Device kernel objects to provide a block device to a client. Other virtualization technologies such as Xen can access the Ceph Block Device kernel object(s). This is done with the command-line tool ``rbd``. .. index:: Ceph FS; Ceph Filesystem; libcephfs; MDS; metadata server; ceph-mds Ceph Filesystem --------------- The Ceph Filesystem (Ceph FS) provides a POSIX-compliant filesystem as a service that is layered on top of the object-based Ceph Storage Cluster. Ceph FS files get mapped to objects that Ceph stores in the Ceph Storage Cluster. Ceph Clients mount a CephFS filesystem as a kernel object or as a Filesystem in User Space (FUSE). .. ditaa:: +-----------------------+ +------------------------+ | CephFS Kernel Object | | CephFS FUSE | +-----------------------+ +------------------------+ +---------------------------------------------------+ | Ceph FS Library (libcephfs) | +---------------------------------------------------+ +---------------------------------------------------+ | Ceph Storage Cluster Protocol (librados) | +---------------------------------------------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ | OSDs | | MDSs | | Monitors | +---------------+ +---------------+ +---------------+ The Ceph Filesystem service includes the Ceph Metadata Server (MDS) deployed with the Ceph Storage cluster. The purpose of the MDS is to to store all the filesystem metadata (directories, file ownership, access modes, etc) in high-availability Ceph Metadata Servers where the metadata resides in memory. The reason for the MDS (a daemon called ``ceph-mds``) is that simple filesystem operations like listing a directory or changing a directory (``ls``, ``cd``) would tax the Ceph OSD Daemons unnecessarily. So separating the metadata from the data means that the Ceph Filesystem can provide high performance services without taxing the Ceph Storage Cluster. Ceph FS separates the metadata from the data, storing the metadata in the MDS, and storing the file data in one or more objects in the Ceph Storage Cluster. The Ceph filesystem aims for POSIX compatibility. ``ceph-mds`` can run as a single process, or it can be distributed out to multiple physical machines, either for high availability or for scalability. - **High Availability**: The extra ``ceph-mds`` instances can be `standby`, ready to take over the duties of any failed ``ceph-mds`` that was `active`. This is easy because all the data, including the journal, is stored on RADOS. The transition is triggered automatically by ``ceph-mon``. - **Scalability**: Multiple ``ceph-mds`` instances can be `active`, and they will split the directory tree into subtrees (and shards of a single busy directory), effectively balancing the load amongst all `active` servers. Combinations of `standby` and `active` etc are possible, for example running 3 `active` ``ceph-mds`` instances for scaling, and one `standby` instance for high availability. .. _RADOS - A Scalable, Reliable Storage Service for Petabyte-scale Storage Clusters: http://ceph.com/papers/weil-rados-pdsw07.pdf .. _Paxos: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paxos_(computer_science) .. _Monitor Config Reference: ../rados/configuration/mon-config-ref .. _Monitoring OSDs and PGs: ../rados/operations/monitoring-osd-pg .. _Heartbeats: ../rados/configuration/mon-osd-interaction .. _Monitoring OSDs: ../rados/operations/monitoring-osd-pg/#monitoring-osds .. _CRUSH - Controlled, Scalable, Decentralized Placement of Replicated Data: http://ceph.com/papers/weil-crush-sc06.pdf .. _Data Scrubbing: ../rados/configuration/osd-config-ref#scrubbing .. _Report Peering Failure: ../rados/configuration/mon-osd-interaction#osds-report-peering-failure .. _Troubleshooting Peering Failure: ../rados/troubleshooting/troubleshooting-pg#placement-group-down-peering-failure .. _Ceph Authentication and Authorization: ../rados/operations/auth-intro/ .. _Hardware Recommendations: ../install/hardware-recommendations .. _Network Config Reference: ../rados/configuration/network-config-ref .. _Data Scrubbing: ../rados/configuration/osd-config-ref#scrubbing .. _striping: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_striping .. _RAID: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAID .. _RAID 0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAID_0#RAID_0 .. _Ceph Object Storage: ../radosgw/ .. _RESTful: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RESTful .. _Erasure Code Notes: https://github.com/ceph/ceph/blob/40059e12af88267d0da67d8fd8d9cd81244d8f93/doc/dev/osd_internals/erasure_coding/developer_notes.rst .. _Cache Tiering: ../rados/operations/cache-tiering .. _Set Pool Values: ../rados/operations/pools#set-pool-values