PolicyDifference: implement constraints diff

Closes #63
This commit is contained in:
Chris PeBenito 2016-02-05 09:12:36 -05:00
parent 64043865e4
commit b1b1a36ae2
7 changed files with 663 additions and 9 deletions

87
sediff
View File

@ -70,6 +70,14 @@ mlsrule = parser.add_argument_group("MLS rule differences")
mlsrule.add_argument("--range_trans", action="store_true",
help="Print range_transition rule differences")
constrain = parser.add_argument_group("Constraint differences")
constrain.add_argument("--constrain", action="store_true", help="Print constrain differences")
constrain.add_argument("--mlsconstrain", action="store_true", help="Print mlsconstrain differences")
constrain.add_argument("--validatetrans", action="store_true",
help="Print validatetrans differences")
constrain.add_argument("--mlsvalidatetrans", action="store_true",
help="Print mlsvalidatetrans differences")
labeling = parser.add_argument_group("labeling statement differences")
labeling.add_argument("--initialsid", action="store_true", help="Print initial SID differences")
labeling.add_argument("--fs_use", action="store_true", help="Print fs_use_* differences")
@ -92,7 +100,8 @@ all_differences = not any((args.class_, args.common, args.type_, args.attribute,
args.type_trans, args.type_change, args.type_member, args.role_allow,
args.role_trans, args.range_trans, args.initialsid, args.genfscon,
args.netifcon, args.nodecon, args.portcon, args.fs_use, args.polcap,
args.property, args.default))
args.property, args.default, args.constrain, args.mlsconstrain,
args.validatetrans, args.mlsvalidatetrans))
if args.debug:
logging.basicConfig(level=logging.DEBUG,
@ -797,6 +806,82 @@ try:
print()
if all_differences or args.constrain:
if diff.added_constrains or diff.removed_constrains or args.constrain:
print("Constraints ({0} Added, {1} Removed)".format(
len(diff.added_constrains), len(diff.removed_constrains)))
if diff.added_constrains and not args.stats:
print(" Added Constraints: {0}".format(
len(diff.added_constrains)))
for r in sorted(diff.added_constrains):
print(" + {0}".format(r))
if diff.removed_constrains and not args.stats:
print(" Removed Constraints: {0}".format(
len(diff.removed_constrains)))
for r in sorted(diff.removed_constrains):
print(" - {0}".format(r))
print()
if all_differences or args.mlsconstrain:
if diff.added_mlsconstrains or diff.removed_mlsconstrains or args.mlsconstrain:
print("MLS Constraints ({0} Added, {1} Removed)".format(
len(diff.added_mlsconstrains), len(diff.removed_mlsconstrains)))
if diff.added_mlsconstrains and not args.stats:
print(" Added MLS Constraints: {0}".format(
len(diff.added_mlsconstrains)))
for r in sorted(diff.added_mlsconstrains):
print(" + {0}".format(r))
if diff.removed_mlsconstrains and not args.stats:
print(" Removed MLS Constraints: {0}".format(
len(diff.removed_mlsconstrains)))
for r in sorted(diff.removed_mlsconstrains):
print(" - {0}".format(r))
print()
if all_differences or args.validatetrans:
if diff.added_validatetrans or diff.removed_validatetrans or args.validatetrans:
print("Validatetrans ({0} Added, {1} Removed)".format(
len(diff.added_validatetrans), len(diff.removed_validatetrans)))
if diff.added_validatetrans and not args.stats:
print(" Added Validatetrans: {0}".format(
len(diff.added_validatetrans)))
for r in sorted(diff.added_validatetrans):
print(" + {0}".format(r))
if diff.removed_validatetrans and not args.stats:
print(" Removed Validatetrans: {0}".format(
len(diff.removed_validatetrans)))
for r in sorted(diff.removed_validatetrans):
print(" - {0}".format(r))
print()
if all_differences or args.mlsvalidatetrans:
if diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans or diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans or args.mlsvalidatetrans:
print("MLS Validatetrans ({0} Added, {1} Removed)".format(
len(diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans), len(diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans)))
if diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans and not args.stats:
print(" Added MLS Validatetrans: {0}".format(
len(diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)))
for r in sorted(diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans):
print(" + {0}".format(r))
if diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans and not args.stats:
print(" Removed MLS Validatetrans: {0}".format(
len(diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans)))
for r in sorted(diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans):
print(" - {0}".format(r))
print()
if all_differences or args.initialsid:
if diff.added_initialsids or diff.removed_initialsids or diff.modified_initialsids \
or args.initialsid:

View File

@ -18,6 +18,7 @@
#
from .bool import BooleansDifference
from .commons import CommonDifference
from .constraints import ConstraintsDifference
from .default import DefaultsDifference
from .fsuse import FSUsesDifference
from .genfscon import GenfsconsDifference
@ -43,6 +44,7 @@ __all__ = ['PolicyDifference']
class PolicyDifference(BooleansDifference,
CategoriesDifference,
CommonDifference,
ConstraintsDifference,
DefaultsDifference,
FSUsesDifference,
GenfsconsDifference,

220
setools/diff/constraints.py Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,220 @@
# Copyright 2016, Tresys Technology, LLC
#
# This file is part of SETools.
#
# SETools is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
# it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License as
# published by the Free Software Foundation, either version 2.1 of
# the License, or (at your option) any later version.
#
# SETools is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
# but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
# MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the
# GNU Lesser General Public License for more details.
#
# You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
# License along with SETools. If not, see
# <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
#
from collections import namedtuple
from .descriptors import DiffResultDescriptor
from .difference import Difference, SymbolWrapper, Wrapper
class ConstraintsDifference(Difference):
"""
Determine the difference in constraints between two policies.
Since the compiler does not union constraints, there may be multiple
constraints with the same ruletype, object class, and permission
set, so constraints can only be added or removed, not modified.
The constraint expressions are compared only on a basic level.
Expressions that are logically equivalent but are structurally
different, for example, by associativity, will be considered
different. Type and role attributes are also not expanded,
so if there are changes to attribute members, it will not
be reflected as a difference.
"""
added_constrains = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_constrains")
removed_constrains = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_constrains")
added_mlsconstrains = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_mlsconstrains")
removed_mlsconstrains = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_mlsconstrains")
added_validatetrans = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_validatetrans")
removed_validatetrans = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_validatetrans")
added_mlsvalidatetrans = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_mlsvalidatetrans")
removed_mlsvalidatetrans = DiffResultDescriptor("diff_mlsvalidatetrans")
# Lists of rules for each policy
_left_constrains = None
_right_constrains = None
_left_mlsconstrains = None
_right_mlsconstrains = None
_left_validatetrans = None
_right_validatetrans = None
_left_mlsvalidatetrans = None
_right_mlsvalidatetrans = None
def diff_constrains(self):
"""Generate the difference in constraint rules between the policies."""
self.log.info("Generating constraint differences from {0.left_policy} to {0.right_policy}".
format(self))
if self._left_constrains is None or self._right_constrains is None:
self._create_constrain_lists()
self.added_constrains, self.removed_constrains, _ = self._set_diff(
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._left_constrains),
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._right_constrains))
def diff_mlsconstrains(self):
"""Generate the difference in MLS constraint rules between the policies."""
self.log.info(
"Generating MLS constraint differences from {0.left_policy} to {0.right_policy}".
format(self))
if self._left_mlsconstrains is None or self._right_mlsconstrains is None:
self._create_constrain_lists()
self.added_mlsconstrains, self.removed_mlsconstrains, _ = self._set_diff(
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._left_mlsconstrains),
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._right_mlsconstrains))
def diff_validatetrans(self):
"""Generate the difference in validatetrans rules between the policies."""
self.log.info(
"Generating validatetrans differences from {0.left_policy} to {0.right_policy}".
format(self))
if self._left_validatetrans is None or self._right_validatetrans is None:
self._create_constrain_lists()
self.added_validatetrans, self.removed_validatetrans, _ = self._set_diff(
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._left_validatetrans),
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._right_validatetrans))
def diff_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""Generate the difference in MLS validatetrans rules between the policies."""
self.log.info(
"Generating mlsvalidatetrans differences from {0.left_policy} to {0.right_policy}".
format(self))
if self._left_mlsvalidatetrans is None or self._right_mlsvalidatetrans is None:
self._create_constrain_lists()
self.added_mlsvalidatetrans, self.removed_mlsvalidatetrans, _ = self._set_diff(
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._left_mlsvalidatetrans),
(ConstraintWrapper(c) for c in self._right_mlsvalidatetrans))
#
# Internal functions
#
def _create_constrain_lists(self):
"""Create rule lists for both policies."""
self._left_constrains = []
self._left_mlsconstrains = []
self._left_validatetrans = []
self._left_mlsvalidatetrans = []
for rule in self.left_policy.constraints():
if rule.ruletype == "constrain":
self._left_constrains.append(rule)
elif rule.ruletype == "mlsconstrain":
self._left_mlsconstrains.append(rule)
elif rule.ruletype == "validatetrans":
self._left_validatetrans.append(rule)
elif rule.ruletype == "mlsvalidatetrans":
self._left_mlsvalidatetrans.append(rule)
else:
self.log.error("Unknown rule type: {0} (This is an SETools bug)".
format(rule.ruletype))
self._right_constrains = []
self._right_mlsconstrains = []
self._right_validatetrans = []
self._right_mlsvalidatetrans = []
for rule in self.right_policy.constraints():
if rule.ruletype == "constrain":
self._right_constrains.append(rule)
elif rule.ruletype == "mlsconstrain":
self._right_mlsconstrains.append(rule)
elif rule.ruletype == "validatetrans":
self._right_validatetrans.append(rule)
elif rule.ruletype == "mlsvalidatetrans":
self._right_mlsvalidatetrans.append(rule)
else:
self.log.error("Unknown rule type: {0} (This is an SETools bug)".
format(rule.ruletype))
def _reset_diff(self):
"""Reset diff results on policy changes."""
self.log.debug("Resetting all constraints differences")
self.added_constrains = None
self.removed_constrains = None
self.added_mlsconstrains = None
self.removed_mlsconstrains = None
self.added_validatetrans = None
self.removed_validatetrans = None
self.added_mlsvalidatetrans = None
self.removed_mlsvalidatetrans = None
# Sets of rules for each policy
self._left_constrains = None
self._left_mlsconstrains = None
self._left_validatetrans = None
self._left_mlsvalidatetrans = None
self._right_constrains = None
self._right_mlsconstrains = None
self._right_validatetrans = None
self._right_mlsvalidatetrans = None
class ConstraintWrapper(Wrapper):
"""Wrap constraints for diff purposes."""
def __init__(self, rule):
self.origin = rule
self.ruletype = rule.ruletype
self.tclass = SymbolWrapper(rule.tclass)
try:
self.perms = rule.perms
except AttributeError:
# (mls)validatetrans
self.perms = None
self.key = hash(rule)
self.expr = []
for op in rule.postfix_expression():
if isinstance(op, frozenset):
# lists of types/users/roles
self.expr.append(frozenset(SymbolWrapper(item) for item in op))
else:
# strings in the expression such as u1/r1/t1 or "=="
self.expr.append(op)
def __hash__(self):
return self.key
def __lt__(self, other):
return self.key < other.key
def __eq__(self, other):
return self.ruletype == other.ruletype and \
self.tclass == other.tclass and \
self.perms == other.perms and \
self.expr == other.expr

View File

@ -1349,6 +1349,178 @@ class PolicyDifferenceTest(ValidateRule, unittest.TestCase):
self.assertIsNone(added_range)
self.assertIsNone(removed_range)
#
# constrains
#
def test_added_constrains(self):
"""Diff: added constrains."""
l = sorted(self.diff.added_constrains)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
constrain = l[0]
self.assertEqual("constrain", constrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow3", constrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["null"]), constrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(["u1", "u2", "!="], constrain.postfix_expression())
constrain = l[1]
self.assertEqual("constrain", constrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", constrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), constrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(
['u1', 'u2', '==', 'r1', 'r2', '==', 'and', 't1', set(["system"]), '!=', 'or'],
constrain.postfix_expression())
def test_removed_constrains(self):
"""Diff: removed constrains."""
l = sorted(self.diff.removed_constrains)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
constrain = l[0]
self.assertEqual("constrain", constrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow4", constrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), constrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(["u1", "u2", "!="], constrain.postfix_expression())
constrain = l[1]
self.assertEqual("constrain", constrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", constrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), constrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(
['u1', 'u2', '==', 'r1', 'r2', '==', 'and', 't1', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
constrain.postfix_expression())
#
# mlsconstrains
#
def test_added_mlsconstrains(self):
"""Diff: added mlsconstrains."""
l = sorted(self.diff.added_mlsconstrains)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
mlsconstrain = l[0]
self.assertEqual("mlsconstrain", mlsconstrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow3", mlsconstrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["null"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'domby', 'and',
't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '!=', 'or'],
mlsconstrain.postfix_expression())
mlsconstrain = l[1]
self.assertEqual("mlsconstrain", mlsconstrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsconstrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'incomp',
'and', 't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsconstrain.postfix_expression())
def test_removed_mlsconstrains(self):
"""Diff: removed mlsconstrains."""
l = sorted(self.diff.removed_mlsconstrains)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
mlsconstrain = l[0]
self.assertEqual("mlsconstrain", mlsconstrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow4", mlsconstrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_w"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'domby', 'and',
't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsconstrain.postfix_expression())
mlsconstrain = l[1]
self.assertEqual("mlsconstrain", mlsconstrain.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsconstrain.tclass)
self.assertSetEqual(set(["hi_r"]), mlsconstrain.perms)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', 'domby', 'h1', 'h2', 'dom', 'and', 't1', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsconstrain.postfix_expression())
#
# validatetrans
#
def test_added_validatetrans(self):
"""Diff: added validatetrans."""
l = sorted(self.diff.added_validatetrans)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
validatetrans = l[0]
self.assertEqual("validatetrans", validatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow3", validatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['t1', 't2', '==', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
validatetrans.postfix_expression())
validatetrans = l[1]
self.assertEqual("validatetrans", validatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", validatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['u1', 'u2', '!=', 'r1', 'r2', '==', 'and', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
validatetrans.postfix_expression())
def test_removed_validatetrans(self):
"""Diff: removed validatetrans."""
l = sorted(self.diff.removed_validatetrans)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
validatetrans = l[0]
self.assertEqual("validatetrans", validatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow4", validatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['u1', 'u2', '==', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
validatetrans.postfix_expression())
validatetrans = l[1]
self.assertEqual("validatetrans", validatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", validatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['u1', 'u2', '==', 'r1', 'r2', '!=', 'and', 't3', set(["system"]), '==', 'or'],
validatetrans.postfix_expression())
#
# mlsvalidatetrans
#
def test_added_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""Diff: added mlsvalidatetrans."""
l = sorted(self.diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
mlsvalidatetrans = l[0]
self.assertEqual("mlsvalidatetrans", mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow3", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', '==', 'h1', 'h2', '==', 'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsvalidatetrans.postfix_expression())
mlsvalidatetrans = l[1]
self.assertEqual("mlsvalidatetrans", mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', 'incomp', 'h1', 'h2', 'domby',
'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsvalidatetrans.postfix_expression())
def test_removed_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""Diff: removed mlsvalidatetrans."""
l = sorted(self.diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans)
self.assertEqual(2, len(l))
mlsvalidatetrans = l[0]
self.assertEqual("mlsvalidatetrans", mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow4", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', '==', 'h1', 'h2', '==', 'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsvalidatetrans.postfix_expression())
mlsvalidatetrans = l[1]
self.assertEqual("mlsvalidatetrans", mlsvalidatetrans.ruletype)
self.assertEqual("infoflow5", mlsvalidatetrans.tclass)
self.assertListEqual(
['l1', 'l2', 'dom', 'h1', 'h2', 'dom', 'and', 't3', set(["mls_exempt"]), '==', 'or'],
mlsvalidatetrans.postfix_expression())
class PolicyDifferenceTestNoDiff(unittest.TestCase):
@ -1695,6 +1867,38 @@ class PolicyDifferenceTestNoDiff(unittest.TestCase):
"""NoDiff: no modified defaults."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_defaults)
def test_added_constrains(self):
"""NoDiff: no added constrains."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_constrains)
def test_removed_constrains(self):
"""NoDiff: no removed constrains."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_constrains)
def test_added_mlsconstrains(self):
"""NoDiff: no added mlsconstrains."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsconstrains)
def test_removed_mlsconstrains(self):
"""NoDiff: no removed mlsconstrains."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_mlsconstrains)
def test_added_validatetrans(self):
"""NoDiff: no added validatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_validatetrans)
def test_removed_validatetrans(self):
"""NoDiff: no removed validatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_validatetrans)
def test_added_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""NoDiff: no added mlsvalidatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)
def test_removed_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""NoDiff: no removed mlsvalidatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans)
class PolicyDifferenceTestMLStoStandard(unittest.TestCase):
@ -2054,3 +2258,39 @@ class PolicyDifferenceTestMLStoStandard(unittest.TestCase):
def test_modified_defaults(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no defaults modified."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.modified_defaults)
def test_added_constraints(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no added constraints."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_constrains)
def test_removed_constraints(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed constraints."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_constrains)
def test_added_validatetrans(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no added validatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_validatetrans)
def test_removed_validatetrans(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no removed validatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.removed_validatetrans)
def test_added_mlsconstraints(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no added mlsconstraints."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsconstrains)
def test_removed_mlsconstraints(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: all mlsconstraints removed."""
self.assertEqual(
sum(1 for m in self.diff.left_policy.constraints() if m.ruletype == "mlsconstrain"),
len(self.diff.removed_mlsconstrains))
def test_added_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: no added mlsvalidatetrans."""
self.assertFalse(self.diff.added_mlsvalidatetrans)
def test_removed_mlsvalidatetrans(self):
"""MLSvsStandardDiff: all mlsvalidatetrans removed."""
self.assertEqual(
sum(1 for m in self.diff.left_policy.constraints() if m.ruletype == "mlsvalidatetrans"),
len(self.diff.removed_mlsvalidatetrans))

View File

@ -151,9 +151,28 @@ level s44:c0.c4;
level s45:c0.c4;
level s47:c0.c4;
#some constraints
# matching mls constraints
mlsconstrain infoflow hi_r ((l1 dom l2) or (t1 == mls_exempt));
# added mls constraint
# removed mls constraint
mlsconstrain infoflow4 hi_w ((l1 domby l2 and h1 domby h2) or (t1 == mls_exempt));
# remove/add mls constraint (expression change)
mlsconstrain infoflow5 hi_r ((l1 domby l2 and h1 dom h2) or (t1 == mls_exempt));
# matching mls validatetrans
mlsvalidatetrans infoflow (h1 == h2 or t3 == system);
# added mls validatetrans
# removed mls validatetrans
mlsvalidatetrans infoflow4 ((l1 == l2 and h1 == h2) or t3 == mls_exempt);
# remove/add mls validatetrans (expression change)
mlsvalidatetrans infoflow5 ((l1 dom l2 and h1 dom h2) or (t3 == mls_exempt));
attribute mls_exempt;
attribute an_attr;
attribute removed_attr;
@ -631,8 +650,31 @@ user modified_remove_role roles { system removed_role } level s2 range s2;
user modified_change_level roles system level s2:c0 range s2:c0 - s2:c0,c1;
user modified_change_range roles system level s3:c1 range s3:c1 - s3:c1.c3;
#normal constraints
constrain infoflow hi_w (u1 == u2);
# matching constraints
constrain infoflow hi_w (u1 == u2 or t1 == system);
constrain infoflow hi_w (t1 == t2 or t1 == system);
constrain infoflow hi_r (r1 == r2 or t1 == system);
# added constraint
# removed constraint
constrain infoflow4 hi_w (u1 != u2);
# remove/add constraint (expression change)
constrain infoflow5 hi_r ((u1 == u2 and r1 == r2) or (t1 == system));
# matching validatetrans
validatetrans infoflow (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
validatetrans infoflow (r1 == r2 or t3 == system);
validatetrans infoflow2 (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
# added validatetrans
# removed validatetrans
validatetrans infoflow4 (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
# remove/add validatetrans (expression change)
validatetrans infoflow5 ((u1 == u2 and r1 != r2) or (t3 == system));
#isids
sid kernel system:system:system:s0

View File

@ -572,8 +572,31 @@ user modified_remove_role roles { system removed_role };
user modified_change_level roles system;
user modified_change_range roles system;
#normal constraints
constrain infoflow hi_w (u1 == u2);
# matching constraints
constrain infoflow hi_w (u1 == u2 or t1 == system);
constrain infoflow hi_w (t1 == t2 or t1 == system);
constrain infoflow hi_r (r1 == r2 or t1 == system);
# added constraint
# removed constraint
constrain infoflow4 hi_w (u1 != u2);
# remove/add constraint (expression change)
constrain infoflow5 hi_r ((u1 == u2 and r1 == r2) or (t1 == system));
# matching validatetrans
validatetrans infoflow (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
validatetrans infoflow (r1 == r2 or t3 == system);
validatetrans infoflow2 (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
# added validatetrans
# removed validatetrans
validatetrans infoflow4 (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
# remove/add validatetrans (expression change)
validatetrans infoflow5 ((u1 == u2 and r1 != r2) or (t3 == system));
#isids
sid kernel system:system:system

View File

@ -151,9 +151,28 @@ level s44:c0.c4;
level s45:c0.c4;
level s46:c0.c4;
#some constraints
# matching mls constraints
mlsconstrain infoflow hi_r ((l1 dom l2) or (t1 == mls_exempt));
# added mls constraint
mlsconstrain infoflow3 null ((l1 domby l2 and h1 domby h2) or (t1 != mls_exempt));
# removed mls constraint
# remove/add mls constraint (expression change)
mlsconstrain infoflow5 hi_r ((l1 domby l2 and h1 incomp h2) or (t1 == mls_exempt));
# matching mls validatetrans
mlsvalidatetrans infoflow (h1 == h2 or t3 == system);
# added mls validatetrans
mlsvalidatetrans infoflow3 ((l1 == l2 and h1 == h2) or t3 == mls_exempt);
# removed mls validatetrans
# remove/add mls validatetrans (expression change)
mlsvalidatetrans infoflow5 ((l1 incomp l2 and h1 domby h2) or (t3 == mls_exempt));
attribute mls_exempt;
attribute an_attr;
attribute added_attr;
@ -631,8 +650,31 @@ user modified_remove_role roles system level s2 range s2;
user modified_change_level roles system level s2:c1 range s2:c1 - s2:c0,c1;
user modified_change_range roles system level s3:c1 range s3:c1 - s3:c1.c4;
#normal constraints
constrain infoflow hi_w (u1 == u2);
# matching constraints
constrain infoflow hi_w (u1 == u2 or t1 == system);
constrain infoflow hi_w (t1 == t2 or t1 == system);
constrain infoflow hi_r (r1 == r2 or t1 == system);
# added constraint
constrain infoflow3 null (u1 != u2);
# removed constraint
# remove/add constraint (expression change)
constrain infoflow5 hi_r ((u1 == u2 and r1 == r2) or (t1 != system));
# matching validatetrans
validatetrans infoflow (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
validatetrans infoflow (r1 == r2 or t3 == system);
validatetrans infoflow2 (u1 == u2 or t3 == system);
# added validatetrans
validatetrans infoflow3 (t1 == t2 or t3 == system);
# removed validatetrans
# remove/add validatetrans (expression change)
validatetrans infoflow5 ((u1 != u2 and r1 == r2) or (t3 == system));
#isids
sid kernel system:system:system:s0