This seems more useful in general. This change also happens to fix a
miscounting of preroll packets when some of them were "rounded" away,
and which could make it stuck.
Also a simple intra-refresh encode with x264 (and muxed to mkv by it)
seems to work now. I guess I misinterpreted earlier results.
Backstepping still could get "stuck" if the demuxer didn't seek far back
enough. This commit fixes getting stuck if playing backwards from the
end, and audio has ended much earlier than the video.
In commit 4544fb0856, I claimed that the backward seek semantics
("snapping" backward in normal seeking, unrelated to backward playing)
would take care of this. Unfortunately, this is not always quite true.
In theory, a seek to any position (that does not use SEEK_FORWARD, i.e.
backward snapping) should return a packet for every stream. But I have a
mkv sample, where audio ends much earlier than video. Its mkvmerge
created index does not have entries for audio packets, so the video
index is used. This index has its last entry somewhere close after the
end of audio. So no audio packets will be returned. With a "too small"
back_seek_size, the demuxer will retry a seek target that ends up in
this place forever. (This does not happen if you use --index=recreate.
It also doesn't happen with libavformat, which always prefers its own
index, while mpv's internal mkv demuxer strictly prefers the index from
the file if it can be read.)
Fix this by adding the back_seek_size every time we fail to see enough
packets. This way the seek step can add up until it works.
To prevent that back_seek_pos just "runs away" towards negative infinity
by subtracting back_seek_size every time we back step to undo forward
reading (e.g. if --no-cache is used), readjust the back_seek_pos to the
lowest known resume position. (If the cache is active, kf_seek_pts can
be used, but to work in all situations, the code needs to grab the
minimum PTS in the keyframe range.)
Just rearranging shit. Setting SEEK_HR for backstep seeks actually
doesn't have much meaning, but disables the weird audio snapping for
"keyframe" seeks, and I don't know it's late.
This code used to be simpler, but now it's enough that it should be
factored into a single function.
Both uses of the new function are annoyingly different. The first use is
the special case when a decoder tries to read packets, but the demuxer
doesn't see any (like mp4 files with sparse video packets, which
actually turned out to be chapter thumbnail "tracks"). Then the other
stream queues will overflow, and the stream with no packets is marked
EOF to avoid stalling playback.
The second case is when the demxuer returns global EOF.
It would be more awkward to have the loop iterating the streams in the
function, because then you'd need a weird parameter to control the
behavior.
Just "mpv file.mkv --play-direction=backward" did not work, because
backward demuxing from the very end was not implemented. This is another
corner case, because the resume mechanism so far requires a packet
"position" (dts or pos) as reference. Now "EOF" is another possible
reference.
Also, the backstep mechanism could cause streams to find different
playback start positions, basically leading to random playback start
(instead of what you specified with --start). This happens only if
backstep seeks are involved (i.e. no cached data yet), but since this is
usually the case at playback start, it always happened. It was racy too,
because it depended on the order the decoders on other threads requested
new data. The comment below "resume_earlier" has some more blabla.
Some other details are changed.
I'm giving up on the "from_cache" parameter, and don't try to detect the
situation when the demuxer does not seek properly. Instead, always seek
back, hopefully some more.
Instead of trying to adjust the backstep seek target by a random value
of 1.0 seconds. Instead, always rely on the random value provided by the
user via --demuxer-backward-playback-step. If the demuxer should really
get "stuck" and somehow miss the seek target badly, or the user sets the
option value to 0, then the demuxer will not make any progress and just
eat CPU. (Although due to backward seek semantics used for backstep
seeks, even a very small seek step size will work. Just not 0.)
It seems this also fixes backstepping correctly when the initial seek
ended at the last keyframe range. (The explanation above was about the
case when it ends at EOF. These two cases are different. In the former,
you just need to step to the previous keyframe range, which was broken
because it didn't always react correctly to reaching EOF. In the latter,
you need to do a separate search for the last keyframe.)
In this scenario, the demuxer will output timestamps offset by the codec
delay (e.g. negative timestamps at the start; mkv simulates those), and
the trimming in the decoder (often libavcodec, but ad_lavc.c in our
case) will adjust the timestamps back (e.g. stream actually starts at
0).
This offset needs to be taken into account when seeking. This worked in
the uncached case. (demux_mkv.c is a bit tricky in that the index is
already in the offset space, so it compensates even though the seek call
does not reference codec_delay.) But in the cached case, seeks backwards
did not seek enough, and forward they seeked too much.
Fix this by adding the codec delay to the index search. We need to get
"earlier" packets, so e.g. seeking to position 0 really gets the initial
packets with negative timestamps.
This also adjusts the seek range start. This is also pretty obvious: if
the beginning of the file is cached, the seek range should start at 0,
not a negative value. We compare 0-based timestamps to it later on.
Not sure if this is the best approach. I also could have thought
about/checked some corner cases harder. But fuck this shit.
Not fixing duration (who cares) or end trimming, which would reduce the
seek range and duration (who cares).
Only timestamps that enter or leave the demuxer API should be adjusted
by ts_offset (which is usually the start time). queue_seek() is also
used by backward demux seeks, which uses an internal timestamp.
I refactored this in a previous commit, and my testing was insufficient.
This appeared to work - by coincidence this demuxed the video stream in
some tests files (so it appeared to work to me), but all other packets
were discarded and leaked.
Fixes: fec3a4792a
See manpage additions. This is a huge hack. You can bet there are shit
tons of bugs. It's literally forcing square pegs into round holes.
Hopefully, the manpage wall of text makes it clear enough that the whole
shit can easily crash and burn. (Although it shouldn't literally crash.
That would be a bug. It possibly _could_ start a fire by entering some
sort of endless loop, not a literal one, just something where it tries
to do work without making progress.)
(Some obvious bugs I simply ignored for this initial version, but
there's a number of potential bugs I can't even imagine. Normal playback
should remain completely unaffected, though.)
How this works is also described in the manpage. Basically, we demux in
reverse, then we decode in reverse, then we render in reverse.
The decoding part is the simplest: just reorder the decoder output. This
weirdly integrates with the timeline/ordered chapter code, which also
has special requirements on feeding the packets to the decoder in a
non-straightforward way (it doesn't conflict, although a bugmessmass
breaks correct slicing of segments, so EDL/ordered chapter playback is
broken in backward direction).
Backward demuxing is pretty involved. In theory, it could be much
easier: simply iterating the usual demuxer output backward. But this
just doesn't fit into our code, so there's a cthulhu nightmare of shit.
To be specific, each stream (audio, video) is reversed separately. At
least this means we can do backward playback within cached content (for
example, you could play backwards in a live stream; on that note, it
disables prefetching, which would lead to losing new live video, but
this could be avoided).
The fuckmess also meant that I didn't bother trying to support
subtitles. Subtitles are a problem because they're "sparse" streams.
They need to be "passively" demuxed: you don't try to read a subtitle
packet, you demux audio and video, and then look whether there was a
subtitle packet. This means to get subtitles for a time range, you need
to know that you demuxed video and audio over this range, which becomes
pretty messy when you demux audio and video backwards separately.
Backward display is the most weird (and potentially buggy) part. To
avoid that we need to touch a LOT of timing code, we negate all
timestamps. The basic idea is that due to the navigation, all
comparisons and subtractions of timestamps keep working, and you don't
need to touch every single of them to "reverse" them.
E.g.:
bool before = pts_a < pts_b;
would need to be:
bool before = forward
? pts_a < pts_b
: pts_a > pts_b;
or:
bool before = pts_a * dir < pts_b * dir;
or if you, as it's implemented now, just do this after decoding:
pts_a *= dir;
pts_b *= dir;
and then in the normal timing/renderer code:
bool before = pts_a < pts_b;
Consequently, we don't need many changes in the latter code. But some
assumptions inhererently true for forward playback may have been broken
anyway. What is mainly needed is fixing places where values are passed
between positive and negative "domains". For example, seeking and
timestamp user display always uses positive timestamps. The main mess is
that it's not obvious which domain a given variable should or does use.
Well, in my tests with a single file, it suddenly started to work when I
did this. I'm honestly surprised that it did, and that I didn't have to
change a single line in the timing code past decoder (just something
minor to make external/cached text subtitles display). I committed it
immediately while avoiding thinking about it. But there really likely
are subtle problems of all sorts.
As far as I'm aware, gstreamer also supports backward playback. When I
looked at this years ago, I couldn't find a way to actually try this,
and I didn't revisit it now. Back then I also read talk slides from the
person who implemented it, and I'm not sure if and which ideas I might
have taken from it. It's possible that the timestamp reversal is
inspired by it, but I didn't check. (I think it claimed that it could
avoid large changes by changing a sign?)
VapourSynth has some sort of reverse function, which provides a backward
view on a video. The function itself is trivial to implement, as
VapourSynth aims to provide random access to video by frame numbers (so
you just request decreasing frame numbers). From what I remember, it
wasn't exactly fluid, but it worked. It's implemented by creating an
index, and seeking to the target on demand, and a bunch of caching. mpv
could use it, but it would either require using VapourSynth as demuxer
and decoder for everything, or replacing the current file every time
something is supposed to be played backwards.
FFmpeg's libavfilter has reversal filters for audio and video. These
require buffering the entire media data of the file, and don't really
fit into mpv's architecture. It could be used by playing a libavfilter
graph that also demuxes, but that's like VapourSynth but worse.
The demuxer layer can start a thread to decouple the rest of the player
from blocking I/O (such as network accesses). But this particular
function does not support running with the thread enabled. The mutex use
within it is only since thread_work() may temporarily unlock the mutex,
and unlocking an unlocked mutex is not allowed. Most of the rest of the
code still does proper locking, even if it's pointless and effectively
single-threaded.
To make this look slightly cleaner, extend the mutex around the rest of
the code (like threaded code would have to do). This is mostly a
cosmetic change.
The demuxer cache benefits slightly from knowing where the current file
or stream begins. For example, seeking "left most" when the start is
cached would not trigger a low level seek (which would be followed by
messy range joining when it notices that the newly demuxed packets
overlap with an existing range).
Unfortunately, since multimedia is so crazy (or actually FFmpeg in its
quite imperfect attempt to be able to demux anything), it's hard to tell
where a file starts. There is no feedback whether a specific seek went
to the start of the file. Packets are not tagged with a flag indicating
they were demuxed from the start position. There is no index available
that could be used to cross-check this (even if the file contains a full
and "perfect" index, like mp4). You could go by the timestamps, but who
says streams start at 0? Streams can start somewhere at an extremely
high timestamps (transport streams like to do that), or they could start
at negative times (e.g. files with audio pre-padding will do that), and
maybe some file formats simply allow negative timestamps and could start
at any negative time. Even if the affected file formats don't allow it
in theory, they may in practice. In addition, FFmpeg exports a
start_time field, which may or may not be useful. (mpv's internal mkv
demuxer also exports such a field, but doesn't bother to set it for
efficiency and robustness reasons.)
Anyway, this is all a huge load of crap, so I decided that if the user
performs a seek command to time 0 or earlier, we consider the first
packet demuxed from each stream to be at the start of the file. In
addition, just trust the start_time field. This is the "shitty" part of
this commit.
One common case of negative timestamps is audio pre-padding. Demuxers
normally behave sanely, and will treat 0 as the start of the file, and
the first packets demuxed will have negative timestamps (since they
contain data to discard), which doesn't break our assumptions in this
commit. (Although, unfortunately, do break some other demuxer cache
assumptions, and the first cached range will be shown as starting at a
negative time.)
Implementation-wise, this is quite simple. Just split the existing
initial_state flag into two, since we want to deal with two separate
aspects. In addition, this avoids the refresh seek on track switching
when it happens right after a seek, instead of only after opening the
demuxer.
There were 3 packet reading functions: the "old" demux_read_packet()
that blocked (leftover from MPlayer times, but was still used until
recently by some obscure code), the "new" demux_read_packet_async(), and
the special demux_read_any_packet(), that is used by pseudo-demuxers
like demux_edl.
The first two could be used both in threaded and un-threaded mode. This
made 5 cases in total. Some bits of logic was spread across all of them.
Unify the logic. A recent commit made demux_read_packet() private, and
the code for it in threaded mode disappears. The difference between
threaded and un-threaded is minimized.
It's possible that this commit causes random regression. Enjoy.
This is a regression. According to git bisect, commit 4b2cbefc0 broke
this. I'm not sure why; the commit in question should have been a
refactor with no functional changes. The commit message mentions brain
damage, though, and this is where I stopped my investigation.
Since with --no-demuxer-thread, there is no read-ahead, the concept of
an underrun makes no sense. We might block the playback thread long
enough that the user perceives an interruption, but we don't know about
this, nor do we care. Only when the demuxer is threaded it can happen
that we can't immediately return a packet to the user, and this
underrun.
(The underrun detection is a bit janky and roundabout, to be honest.
Probably could be simpler by setting a per-stream underrun flag simply
when no packet/EOF is available when the decoder reads a packet.)
It's interesting that the regression existed for half a year, yet nobody
cared. I guess nobody uses --no-demuxer-thread.
Fixes: 4b2cbefc0d
There are 3 packet reading functions in the demux API, which all
function completely differently. One of them, demux_read_packet(), has
only 1 caller, which is in dec_sub.c. Change this caller to use
demux_read_packet_async() instead. Since it really wants to do a
blocking call, setup some proper waiting. This uses mp_dispatch_queue,
because even though it's overkill, it needs the least code.
In practice, waiting actually never happens. This code is only called on
code paths where everything is already read into memory (libavformat's
subtitle demuxers simply behave this way). It's still a bit of a
"coincidence", so implement it properly anyway.
If suubtitle decoder init fails, we still need to unset the demuxer
wakeup callback. Add a sub_destroy() call to the failure path. This also
happens to fix a missed pthread_mutex_destroy() call (in practice this
was a nop, or a memory leak on BSDs).
I'm not sure about this, but it looks like a bug. If a stream didn't
have packets, but the joined range does, the stream should obviously
read the packets added by the joined range. Until now, due to
reader_head being NULL, reading was only resumed if a _new_ packet was
added by actual demuxing (in add_packet_locked()), which means the
stream would suddenly skip ahead, past the original end of the joined
range.
Change it so that it will pick up the new range.
Also, clear the skip_to_keyframe flag. Nothing useful can come from this
flag being set; in the first place, the first packet of a range (that
isn't the current range) should start with a keyframe. Some code
probably enforced it (although it's fuzzy).
Completely untested.
When doing a seek to the end of the cache, ds->skip_to_keyframe can be
set to true. Then some packets passed to add_packet_locked() may have to
be skipped. In some aspects, the skipped packet was still treated as if
it was going to be returned to the reader.
It almost doesn't matter though: it only caused a redundant wakeup_ds()
call, and could pass the packet to the stream recorder. Fix it anyway.
This fixes that there were weird delay ("buffering") when seeking into
the last part of a seekable range. The exact case which triggers it if
SEEK_FORWARD is used, and the seek pts is after the second-last
keyframe, but before the end of the range. In that case,
find_seek_target() returned NULL, and the cache layer waited until the
_next_ keyframe the underlying demuxer returned until resuming playback.
find_seek_target() returned NULL, because the last keyframe had
kf_seek_pts unset. This field contains the lowest PTS in the packet
range from the keyframe until the next keyframe (or EOF). For normal
seeks, this is needed because keyframes don't necessarily have the
minimum PTS in the packet range, so it needs to be computed by waiting
for all packets until the next keyframe (or EOF).
Strictly speaking, this behavior was correct, but it meant that the
caller would set ds->skip_to_keyframe, which waits for the next newly
demuxed keyframe. No packets were returned to the decoder until this
happened, usually resulting in the frontend entering "buffering" mode.
What it really needs to do is returning the last keyframe in the cache.
In this situation, the seek target points in the middle of the last
completely cached packet range (as delimited by keyframes), and
SEEK_FORWARD is supposed to skip to the next keyframe. This is in line
with the basic assumptions the packet cache makes (e.g. the keyframe
flag means it's possible to start decoding, and the frames decoded from
it and following packets will strictly have PTS values above the
previous keyframe range). This means in this situation the kf_seek_pts
value doesn't matter either.
So fix this situation by explicitly detecting it and then returning the
last cached keyframe.
Should the search loop look at all packets, instead of only keyframe
ones? This would mean it can know that it's within the last keyframe
range (without looking at queue->seek_end). Maybe this would be a bit
more natural for the SEEK_FORWARD case, but due to PTS reordering it
doesn't sound like a useful thing to do.
Should skip_to_keyframe be checked by the code that sets kf_seek_pts to
a known value? This wouldn't help too much; the frontend would still go
into "buffering" mode for no reason until the packet range is completed,
although it would resume from the correct range.
Should a NULL return always unconditionally use keyframe_latest? This
makes sense because the seek PTS is usually already in the cached range,
so this is the only case that should happen. But there are scary special
cases, like sparse subtitle streams, or other uses of find_seek_target()
which could be out of range now or in future. Basically, don't "risk"
it.
One other potential problem with this is that the "adjust seek target"
code will be disabled in this case. It checks kf_seek_pts, and if it's
unset, the adjustment is not done. Maybe this could be changed to use
the queue's seek_end time, but I'm not sure if this is fully kosher. On
the other hand, I think the main use for this adjustment is with
backwards seeks, so this shouldn't matter.
A previous commit dealing with audio/video stream merging mentioned how
seeking forward entered "buffering" mode for unknown reasons; this
commit fixes this issue.
demux_timeline doesn't do any transport accesses itself. The slave
demuxers do this (these will actually access the stream layer and
perform e.g. network accesses). As a consequence, demux_timeline always
reported 0 bytes read, and network speed display didn't work.
Fix this by awkwardly reporting the amount of read bytes upwards. This
is not very nice, and requires explicit calls whenever the slave "might"
have read data.
Due to the way the reporting is done, it only works if the slaves do not
run demuxer threads, which makes things even less nice. (Fortunately
they don't anyway, because it would be a waste of resources.) Some
identifiers contain the word "hack" as a warning.
Some of the stupidity comes from the fact that demux.c itself resets the
stats randomly in order to calculate the bytes_per_second value, which
is useless for a slave, but of course is still done, because demux.c
itself is not aware of whether it's on the slave or top-level layer.
Unfortunately, this must do.
In theory, the demuxer thread/cache layer should be separated from
demuxer implementations. This would get rid of all the awkwardness and
nonsense. For example, the only threading involved would be the caching
layer, completely separate from demuxers themselves. It'd be the only
thing calculates speed rates for the player frontend, too (instead of
doing it for each demuxer, even if unused).
It was an ugly hack, and the next commit will make it even uglier.
Slightly reduce the ugliness to prevent death of too many brain cells,
though it's still an ugly hack.
The cleanup is really minor, but I guess the following commit would be
much worse otherwise. In particular, this commit checks accesses
(instead of having a public field with evil access rules), which should
avoid misunderstandings and incorrect use. Strictly speaking, the added
field is redundant, but the next commit complicates it a bit.
Bug caused by a recent refactor. The function is not supposed to unlock
the mutex anymore, but the unlock was forgotten on an obscure code path.
This could sometimes lead to crashes, depending on libc behavior (when
an unlocked mutex was unlocked again, or it tries to unlock a mutex
locked by a different thread).
None of those fancy debug tools could tell me that. I found it by
switching to an error checking mutex and wrapping pthread calls into a
macro that checks their return values.
If the number of chapters is 0, the chapter list can be NULL. clang
complains that we pass NULL to qsort(). This is yet another pointless UB
that exists for no reason other than wasting your time.
Evil shit due to a huge ownership/lifetime mess of various objects.
demux_close_stream() caused 1. the mp_cancel handle being lost (fix by
explicitly preserving it on the new dummy stream), and 2. passing a
dangling stream pointer to the timeline "demuxer" (use demuxer->stream,
which will never be a dangling pointer).
As one defensive programming measure, stop accessing the "stream"
variable in open_given_type(), even where it would still work. This
includes removing a redundant line of code, and removing the peak call,
which should not be needed anymore, as the remaining demuxers do this
mostly correctly.
The only thing left is the notification for track switching. Just get
rid of that.
There's probably no real reason to get rid of control(), but why not. I
think I was actually trying to do some real work but fuck that.
Subtitles (and a few other file types, like playlists) are not streamed,
but fully read on opening. This means keeping the file handle or network
socket open is a waste of resources and could cause other weird
behavior. This is why there's a hack to close them after opening.
Change this hack to make the demuxer itself do this, which is less
weird. (Until recently, demuxer->stream ownership was more complex,
which is why it was done this way.)
I always wanted to get rid of this, because it makes the ownership rules
for the stream pointer really awkward. demux_edl.c was the only
remaining user of this. Replace it with a semi-clever idea: the init
segment shit can be used to pass the "file" contents as memory block,
and "memory://" itself provides an empty stream. I have no idea if this
actually works, because I didn't immediately find a test stream (would
have to be some youtube DASH shit).
Instead of going through those weird DEMUXER_CTRLs, query this
information directly. I'm not sure which kind of brain damage made me
use CTRLs for these. Since there are no other DEMUXER_CTRLs that make
sense for the frontend, remove the remaining infrastructure for them
too.
The stream size return was the only thing that still required doing
STREAM_CTRLs from frontend through the demuxer layer. This can be done
much easier, so rip it out. Also rip out the now unused infrastructure
for STREAM_CTRLs via demuxer layer.
Apparently this was so that when playing a video file from a .rar file,
it would load external subtitles with the same name (instead of looking
for mpv's rar:// mangled URL). This was requested on github almost 5
years ago. Seems like a shit feature, and why should I give a fuck? Drop
it, because it complicates some in progress change.
--record-file is nice, but only sometimes. If you watch some sort of
livestream which you want to record, it's actually much nicer not to
record what you're currently "seeing", but anything you're receiving.
I don't ever use them, so kill them.
Linux TV is excessively complex, and whenever I attempted to use it, it
didn't work well or would have required some major work to update it.
(For example, when I tried to use a webcam-type device with tv://, it
worked badly; even the libavdevice garbage worked better.)
The "program" property was rather complex and rather obscure. I didn't
ever use it. Should there ever be a proper use for it (maybe HLS stream
selection?), it should be rewritten anyway.
The demuxer cache is the only cache now. Might need another change to
combat seeking failures in mp4 etc. The only bad thing is the loss of
cache-speed, which was sort of nice to have.
This will enable the player core to terminate the demuxers in a "nicer"
way without having to block on network. If it just used demux_free(), it
would either have to block on network, or like currently, essentially
kill all I/O forcefully.
The API is slightly awkward, because demuxer lifetime is bound to its
allocation. On the other hand, changing that would also be awkward, and
introduce weird in-between states that would have to be handled in tons
of places.
Currently unused, to be user later.
Alway give each demuxer its own mp_cancel instance. This makes
management of the mp_cancel things much easier. Also, instead of having
add/remove functions for mp_cancel slaves, replace them with a simpler
to use set_parent function. Remove cancel_and_free_demuxer(), which had
mpctx as parameter only to check an assumption. With this commit,
demuxers have their own mp_cancel, so add demux_cancel_and_free() which
makes use of it.
